Why You’re Not Supposed to Be Happy: You’re Supposed to Be Whole

Happiness is easy to market. Wholeness ruins your brand.

The Mirage of Happiness

Everyone wants to be happy. It’s the modern commandment—be positive, stay grateful, radiate good vibes. We treat unhappiness like a character flaw, as if sadness means we’ve fallen out of alignment with the universe.

When I started Cynthia Bourgeault’s Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, I thought I was signing up for serenity. Maybe I’d learn a better meditation method, or some new contemplative trick for turning worry into peace. Instead, Cynthia handed me a scalpel and told me to start cutting away everything that wasn’t true.

She doesn’t promise happiness. She promises wholeness. And that’s an entirely different game.

Freedom Isn’t a Buffet

At some point, the spiritual path got rebranded as a lifestyle.
You’re supposed to glow. Keep a gratitude journal. Be the kind of person who says “alignment” in casual conversation.

But real transformation isn’t curated. It’s inconvenient.
Cynthia says freedom doesn’t come from endless options—it comes from saying yes to what’s already unfolding.

That kind of freedom feels less like floating and more like surrendering to undertow.

Weather vs. Climate

We confuse happiness with evolution. If we’re not cheerful, we assume we’ve lost spiritual ground. But happiness is just emotional weather—it shifts with hormones, headlines, and how much coffee you had.

Wholeness is the climate underneath. It’s what doesn’t move when everything else does.

The spiritual life isn’t about chasing better weather. It’s about learning how to stand in the rain without losing your center.

No Freedom in Free Choice

That’s where Cynthia’s teaching hits hard. She says there’s no freedom in free choice. You can’t whiteboard your way to awakening. Freedom isn’t a buffet—it’s a consent.

And once you give that consent, your life stops being yours in the old way. You’re no longer designing your destiny. You’re letting your destiny design you.

Jonah learned that the hard way. God said “Nineveh,” Jonah said “hard pass,” and immediately booked the next ship to anywhere else. Cue the whale. Cue the storm. Cue the cosmic reminder that “free will” often just means “free to suffer until you agree.”

Freedom isn’t doing what you want—it’s the grace that keeps steering you back to where you belong.

The Art of Consent

Cynthia calls that surrender. Virgin Monk Boy calls it getting spiritually mugged by your own destiny.

You don’t get to curate wholeness. You consent to it.

And that means everything you thought you outgrew—rage, envy, exhaustion, pettiness—gets a seat at the same table as your prayer life. Presence doesn’t exile your flaws; it integrates them.

The mind of Christ doesn’t want your mood board. It wants your participation.

The Friction of Transformation

There’s a quiet cruelty in the modern happiness industry. It’s not just the fake positivity; it’s the subtle accusation that if you’re suffering, you’re somehow doing life wrong.

Cynthia—and the lineage she’s drawing from—turns that on its head. Suffering isn’t proof of failure; it’s the friction of transformation. It’s the sacred tension between who you were and who you’re becoming.

The goal isn’t to avoid that tension. It’s to stay conscious in it.

In the Practicing Living Presence course, she talks about the moment when you stop being the manager of your life and start becoming its witness. You stop measuring progress by feelings and start measuring it by fidelity.

Presence, she says, is a willed skill. You have to practice showing up even when the ego is screaming for escape.

And the ego will scream. It was built to survive, not surrender.

When You Stop Chasing Happiness

Every tradition worth its salt points here.
The Buddhists call it equanimity.
The Sufis call it tawakkul—trust in divine unfolding.
Cynthia calls it the mind of Christ.

Whatever language you use, it’s the same shift: from self-improvement to self-emptying, from control to cooperation.

The irony is that once you stop chasing happiness, something gentler starts to surface on its own. A quiet joy. Not the dopamine rush of “everything’s going great,” but the peace of being aligned with what’s true—even when what’s true hurts.

You start realizing that grace isn’t sentimental. It’s structural. It’s built into the physics of your being. The more you say yes, the more everything unnecessary falls away.

It’s not clean. It’s not pretty. But it’s real.

The Wholeness That Remains

Jesus never said, “Blessed are the happy.” He said, “Blessed are the pure in heart.”

That’s not moral purity—it’s inner transparency. The kind of clarity that can hold joy and grief in the same breath without flinching.

So maybe the point of all this isn’t to be happy. Maybe it’s to stop needing to be.

Maybe peace isn’t an achievement at all.
Maybe it’s what’s left when you quit trying to edit the human out of being human.

Blessed be the ones who trade bliss for honesty.
They’re not backsliding.
They’re becoming whole.

— Virgin Monk Boy

---

If this post unhinged your halo, poured some Presence in your posture, or made your inner heretic weep with joy—share it, toss a coin to your scribal renegade, or subscribe for more molten reflections from the margins.

Upgrade to a paid subscription — it’s only $5/month (about 17¢ a day). It keeps the incense burning, the raccoons fed, and unlocks access to the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours and Whispers from the Silence