This post grows out of the same stream as Voluntary Attention vs. Daydreaming. It’s shaped by the “double attention” teaching that shows up again and again in Cynthia Bourgeault’s Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, which itself is a sustained engagement with Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence. What follows is not a call to withdraw from the world, nor a pitch for spiritual numbness dressed up as wisdom. It emerges from a simpler observation: most of our suffering is not caused by experience itself, but by how completely we disappear into it. Double awareness is the practice of staying in contact with the watcher while still meeting the moment as it is.
The Single Awareness Trap
Most people live inside a one-channel system. Attention goes to an object, a thought, a person, a task, a worry, a sensation, and that is where the “I” goes too. We call it normal. We call it focus. We call it being engaged. But a lot of what we call engagement is actually absorption, and absorption comes with a price. When you collapse entirely into what you’re noticing, you lose contact with the field of awareness that holds the noticing.
In practice, this is why a small irritation can become a full mood. It is why a single comment can hijack an entire day. It is why scrolling can feel like ten minutes but steal an hour. The object pulls, attention follows, identity follows, and the watcher goes offline. You are still conscious, but you are not present.
Helminski names this clearly in the language of energy. There is a level of attention where you can be intensely active while still losing yourself in what you are doing. It can look productive. It can even look creative. But it is missing the quiet center that knows it is happening.
What Double Awareness Actually Means
Double awareness is the ability to hold two realities at the same time: the content of experience and the awareness of experiencing. It is the capacity to remain aware of both the ship and the river. The ship is the thought, the feeling, the conversation, the task, the noise of your inner life. The river is the larger field of being in which all of it is occurring.
This matters because the watcher is not a concept. It is a location. When you are in it, your life has space. When you are not, your life becomes a tunnel.
Double awareness is not detachment in the sense most people mean it. It is not stepping away from feeling. It is not “rising above” your humanity. It is not dissociating into some cold spiritual perch. It is closer to widening the frame. You can still feel anger, but anger is no longer the whole room. You can still feel desire, but desire is no longer driving the car. The watcher does not cancel experience. It contextualizes it.
The Watcher Is Not the Ego
One reason this practice matters is that the ego does not like being observed. The ego likes being right, being safe, being justified, being admired, being defended. It does not like being seen as a pattern. It does not like being caught in the act. That is why the simple shift into witnessing can feel like a small rebellion. Something in you steps back and the whole system becomes less compulsive.
This is also why double awareness is different from self-monitoring. Self-monitoring is the ego watching itself and trying to manage the image. Double awareness is awareness itself becoming conscious of itself. One is performance. The other is presence.
If you want a simple diagnostic, notice how it feels. Ego-monitoring feels tight. It has a judgmental tone. It has an agenda. It is always trying to improve something. Witnessing feels spacious. It does not need to fix the moment in order to see it. It has clarity without panic.
The Core Mechanic
In the most practical terms, the practice is this: reserve a portion of attention for being itself. Helminski calls the path “fastidious remembrance.”
The word fastidious is perfect here because it implies care, precision,
is not a one-time awakening. It is a reawakening, again and again, inside ordinary life.
You do not need to hold the watcher continuously. In fact, trying to do that usually turns the practice into strain. The way this develops is more like a pulse. Awareness opens for a moment. You recognize. Then you get pulled back into the ship. Then you remember again. Over time, the pulses become more frequent, and the watcher begins to feel less like a special state and more like a stable ground.
The goal is not to never get lost. The goal is to shorten the time you stay lost before you recognize what happened.
Three Practices to Build Double Awareness
The first practice is the simplest: name the movement of attention. Not out loud necessarily, but inwardly. “Attention just bent.” “I got pulled.” “I’m contracting.” “I’m chasing.” This is not analysis. It is recognition. The recognition itself is the watcher waking up. You cannot do this from inside absorption. The moment you notice the movement, you are already partially free of it.
The second practice is to anchor awareness in the body while staying engaged with the moment. Pick one subtle point as a home base. The contact of your feet with the ground. The sensation of breathing in the chest. The feeling of your hands. Do not force it. Let it be light. You are not trying to meditate your way out of the conversation. You are simply giving attention a second anchor so it stops being dragged around by whatever is loudest.
The third practice is to train double awareness in low-stakes moments so it shows up when the stakes are high. Practice it when you are making coffee. Practice it while reading a text message. Practice it while brushing your teeth. Practice it when you are mildly bored. Practice it when you are mildly pleased. If you only try to practice when you are triggered, you will treat it like an emergency tool instead of a way of living.
Living With Both Hands on the Wheel
Double awareness is not a spiritual accessory. It is how you stop being played by your own inner weather. Without it, the day belongs to whatever captures you first. With it, life begins to reorganize around a deeper center.
You still act. You still speak. You still make decisions. But you are less likely to be driven by unseen forces. A small gap opens between stimulus and reaction, and that gap is not emptiness. It is intelligence. It is choice. It is being.
The world does not need you to withdraw. It needs you to show up without vanishing into the noise. It needs people who can stay aware of the ship without forgetting the river.
That is the whole practice.
And it begins with one quiet move: noticing that you are noticing.
Share the Scrolls
Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.
Become a Supporting Member
Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.
Tip with a coffee
A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥
Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.
Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy
Recommended Reading
(As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. These recommendations support the scrolls at no extra cost to you.)
Living Presence: A Sufi Way to Mindfulness & the Essential Self by Kabir Helminski
Notice what you’re noticing. Pay attention to what you’re paying attention to.
Beautiful, just beautiful. And to answer Janie's question below, I think of this non-dualistic way of walking in the world as the "middle path." Which opens so much up to us. I feel healed every time somebody reminds me that it isn't either/or but rather both/and. The boat and the river. Life and death. Sorrow and joy. Etc.