Why Christian Nationalists Hate Muslims More Than Atheists
Because Atheists Don’t Make Them Feel Spiritually Outworked
Let’s just admit something that everyone can see but no one wants to say.
Christian Nationalists do not get nearly as rattled by atheists as they do by Muslims.
Atheists are easy. Atheists don’t believe in God. Great. You can argue with them. You can call them godless. You can make a documentary about how they ruined Christmas. Everybody goes home feeling righteous.
But Muslims?
Muslims believe in God.
Not casually.
Aggressively.
That’s where the sweating starts.
Atheists Don’t Show Up to the Obedience Gym
An atheist does not wake up at dawn because God told them to.
An atheist does not wash their arms, face, and feet because God said, “Let’s talk.”
An atheist does not interrupt their workday five separate times to physically bow, kneel, and put their forehead on the ground.
There’s no comparison happening there. It’s like competing in a marathon against someone who stayed on the couch. You automatically win.
Christian Nationalists can point at atheists and say, “See? No God. That’s the problem.”
Simple. Clean. No spiritual performance anxiety.
Muslims Treat God Like He Has a Calendar Invite
Now enter Islam.
Five daily prayers. Not when convenient. Not when the worship band hits the bridge just right. Five fixed times.
Before sunrise. Midday. Afternoon. Sunset. Night.
Each one with ritual washing. Actual water. Not “Lord cleanse my heart.” Water on your face at 5:30 in the morning.
Then the movements. Standing. Bowing. Full prostration. Forehead to floor. In public. In rows. In sync.
You don’t have to convert to notice something slightly humiliating about this if your whole political brand is “We take God seriously.”
Because now the question becomes unavoidable:
If God is sovereign, why does He mostly show up on your bumper sticker?
Ramadan Is Not a “Social Media Fast”
Ramadan is thirty straight days of no food or drink from dawn to sunset.
Not “I’m fasting negativity.”
Not “I gave up TikTok for Lent.”
Actual hunger.
At work.
In traffic.
In Texas heat.
And then there’s zakat. Not “We passed the plate.” A percentage. Structured. Expected. Calculated.
Islam assumes that if God is real, He interrupts your appetite and your bank account.
Christian Nationalism often assumes that if God is real, He interrupts the Supreme Court.
Different emphasis.
The Embarrassing Part No One Wants to Admit
Christian Nationalism talks endlessly about submission to God. They say America must kneel before Christ.
But if you can’t get 700 people out of bed at 6:30am for prayer without offering pancakes, maybe the kneeling-for-the-nation speech needs a little editing.
That’s not theology.
That’s optics.
Because once obedience becomes measurable — daily, physical, inconvenient — the comparison gets uncomfortable fast.
Atheists don’t create that discomfort. They opted out.
Muslims create it just by existing.
They show that you can take God literally without controlling Congress. You can structure your life around divine command without owning the school board.
And that is destabilizing.
Because it quietly suggests that obedience might start with your body before it gets to your ballot.
The Real Sting
This isn’t about saying Islam is perfect. It isn’t.
It’s about noticing who triggers existential panic.
It’s not the people who deny God.
It’s the people who act like He might actually be in charge.
Christian Nationalism can handle disbelief.
What it struggles with is being out-obedienced.
Because nothing ruins a “We are the last serious believers” speech faster than someone else who actually set an alarm.
No mysticism required.
Just consistency.
And consistency is ruthless when your theology mostly lives on a yard sign.
The Part They Really Don’t Want to Talk About
And here’s where it gets truly awkward.
Muslims don’t just believe in one sovereign God.
They honor Jesus.
Not as a mascot.
Not as a campaign slogan.
Not as a culture-war prop.
As a prophet.
They revere him. They speak his name with peace upon him. They teach his miracles. They take his call to prayer, fasting, charity, and submission seriously. They don’t treat him as a logo for national identity. They treat him as someone who obeyed God completely.
Now imagine building a movement around “We are the true defenders of Jesus,” and discovering that the group you call a threat actually fasts more consistently, prays more frequently, gives more structurally, and speaks about surrender to God with less political ambition.
That’s not a theological debate.
That’s uncomfortable symmetry.
Because now the comparison isn’t just about God.
It’s about Jesus.
Christian Nationalism wraps Jesus in the flag.
Islam wraps Jesus in reverence.
Please share this where Christian Nationalists will find it :-)
If you enjoyed this and would like to support our efforts you can become a supporting member or leave a tip
Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.
Always suspected that those who were virulently anti-Muslim had sharia envy. That they wanted the power to compel compliance, like the Taliban: lots of guns, freedom to use them, domination of females, absence of women and non-believers in public life. The ultimate anti-DEI.
I always loved teaching Islam in my World Religions classes. So much rich, complicated tradition that no one in the West knows about. Thanks for this series.