What a Christian Government Would Actually Feel Like

From Someone Who’s Been Mugged by the Sermon on the Mount

Nobody warns you that the Sermon on the Mount comes with blunt force trauma. You start out thinking it’s spiritual poetry, and then it jumps you in an alley. One minute you’re nodding along to the Beatitudes, the next you’re flat on your back, bleeding self-importance while Jesus leans over you saying, “You good?” That’s what living under a truly Christian government would feel like. Not patriotic goosebumps. Not a choir of polished smiles reciting the pledge and prayer in the same breath. It would be the slow realization that the kingdom you kept praying for doesn’t exist to protect your comfort.

A Christian economy wouldn’t run on greed wearing Sunday clothes. It would be the strange arithmetic of loaves and fishes, where the more you give, the more you somehow have. Try explaining that to a budget committee and watch the spreadsheet start speaking in tongues. Billionaires wouldn’t exist, not because the state confiscated their wealth, but because they would finally wake up from the nightmare of thinking they needed it. Every ledger would turn into a love letter. Every debt would be forgiven because forgiveness is the only currency heaven respects. Taxes would still exist, but they would feel different. Imagine an IRS staffed by monks handing you a receipt that says, “Thank you for feeding Christ.”

Borders would start to feel like doorways. The immigration policy would be simple: if they knock, open. No one would be deported for being hungry. The only people sent away would be those still building walls after the carpenter’s son tore them down. Citizenship would have nothing to do with paperwork or birthplace. You would belong the moment you showed up with need in your hands.

Justice in that world would not smell like bleach and bureaucracy. It would smell like bread. Prisons would empty faster than seminaries fill. Mercy would replace vengeance, not because people went soft, but because they finally learned what vengeance costs. Judges would become mediators. Guards would become counselors. Victims would be honored without needing to see someone destroyed. Forgiveness would not erase consequence. It would begin healing. The death penalty would disappear the day we admitted we cannot resurrect the innocent.

Healthcare would be a birthright, not a business. Every clinic would follow the Galilee model. Heal first. Paperwork never. Doctors would act like saints in scrubs, and the waiting room would feel like a chapel instead of purgatory. No one would argue about pre-existing conditions because existence itself would qualify you for care. Mental health would be treated like breathing, something everyone deserves help with when it falters.

Foreign policy would sound insane to modern ears. Turning the other cheek is not a popular campaign slogan. But under this reign, peacemaking would be the only real form of patriotism. The military would shrink until its main purpose was disaster relief, rebuilding homes instead of blowing them up. Diplomacy would stop being strategy and become an act of spiritual hygiene. You would love your enemies until they stopped being enemies, which is exactly what love does when you stop managing it.

Elections would be quiet affairs because leadership would no longer be about ego. The greatest would become the least, and the least would be too busy serving soup to care who noticed. Lawmakers would measure success by how many children slept safely last night instead of by GDP. Power would still tempt people, but there would be no mirrors left for pride to admire itself in.

And if that sounds utopian, remember that this is the system most Christians claim to pray for every week when they say, “Thy kingdom come.” They just haven’t done the math on what happens when it actually arrives. The kingdom doesn’t show up waving a flag. It comes as a quiet revolt. Wealth loses its shine. Pride loses its script. The Sermon on the Mount starts collecting overdue payments from our illusions.

A Christian government would not feel righteous. It would feel disorienting. Like being mugged by mercy. Like having your wallet stolen and realizing it was never yours to begin with. Like waking up from the fever dream of deserving more than someone else. It would hurt first, then heal in ways capitalism never could.

Blessed be the ones who learn to govern by washing feet instead of pointing fingers. They may not win elections, but they will inherit something better. The kind of peace that does not need borders, slogans, or spin doctors to survive.

---

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.

If you’d like to help keep the scrolls unrolling, you can:

🌕 Share this post. Spread the word so more wandering souls stumble into the monastery.

🌗 Upgrade to a paid subscription.
It’s only $5/month (about 17¢ a day). Your support keeps the incense burning, the raccoons fed, and unlocks access to The Virgin Monk Boy Book of Hours and Whispers from the Silence—exclusive reflections for those who like their enlightenment with a side of rebellion.

🌑 Tip with a coffee.
A one-time gift that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement with holy caffeine. ☕🔥

Every share, subscription, or sip of coffee says, keep going, monk — the world still needs sacred nonsense.