The Higher Self Has No Buttons: A Spiritual Guide to Not Getting Played
How presence turns every trigger into a doorway
This reflection continues our journey through Cynthia Bourgeault’s Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, based on Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence: A Sufi Way to Mindfulness and the Essential Self. In this chapter, Bourgeault takes one of Helminski’s most practical truths and treats it like a compass: your buttons only exist at the level of the outer self. The deeper self cannot be insulted. It cannot be manipulated. It cannot be provoked. It simply witnesses with clarity and moves with freedom.
This sounds beautiful in philosophy. But real life has a way of stress-testing our spirituality. It does not whisper politely. It kicks the door open and throws us into situations where our old conditioning erupts before we even know what happened. One sarcastic comment, one dismissive glance, one email written without enough warmth, and we are off to the races. Suddenly our “inner stillness” turns out to be a thin layer of calm covering a very jumpy ego.
Bourgeault’s point is not that this reaction is spiritually embarrassing. Her point is that it is diagnostic. Every button someone pushes reveals where you are still identified with your outer self. In her words, these moments “give you a positional fix.” They tell you exactly where you’re standing in consciousness. When you get hooked, you are in personality. When you don’t, you are in presence.
This is not meant to shame you. It’s meant to show you the doorway.
Why Your Outer Self Gets Played So Easily
Helminski describes the outer self as the conditioned self, shaped by childhood patterns, cultural expectations, and the need to manage how we are seen. It runs on the pain-pleasure principle. It is deeply tied to approval and deeply allergic to disapproval. It wants to control impressions, defend its image, and maintain its preferred narrative at all costs.
That is why it reacts so quickly.
Someone questions your competence.
Someone talks down to you.
Someone does not include you.
Someone gets credit for something you did.
Someone misunderstands your intentions.
The outer self cannot handle ambiguity. It cannot tolerate vulnerability. It cannot stay open when it senses danger. So it reacts from instinct, memory, and fear instead of awareness.
From this state, life can push you around like a pawn. Anyone who knows your weak spots — or even stumbles upon them accidentally — can manipulate your mood, steer your reactions, or trigger your defenses. Even strangers can do it. Sometimes even your own thoughts can do it.
You are not being “attacked.” You are being revealed.
The Higher Self Cannot Be Insulted
The higher self is not numb. It is not indifferent. It is not detached in a cold or distant way. It is grounded in a different center of gravity. Because it does not look to the outside world for its sense of identity, it cannot be threatened by the outside world either.
You might still feel the sting of a harsh word or the awkwardness of a confrontation. But the deeper self is not wounded by it. It knows the difference between a passing emotion and the truth of your being. It sees the same situation the outer self sees, but it does not collapse into it. It holds the moment, the emotion, the other person, and the energy all at once without taking any of it personally.
This is what allows truly awakened beings to hold steady in situations where others lose their center. They are not dead to emotion. They are anchored in something deeper than emotion.
The button belongs to the personality.
The freedom belongs to presence.
How to Identify Your Buttons Before Someone Pushes Them
Bourgeault suggests that identifying your buttons is one of the fastest ways to grow. You notice what sparks, not to suppress it, but to understand where you are still hooked.
The most common buttons are unbelievably predictable:
1. The button of being right.
You feel a tightness in the chest or jaw, and you jump into debate mode. You cannot rest until the other person understands or agrees.
2. The button of being understood.
You start explaining your motives with unnecessary detail because you fear being misread or misjudged.
3. The button of being respected.
Tone becomes personal. Even neutral statements feel loaded.
4. The button of being insignificant.
Feeling unseen makes you withdraw, overcompensate, or evaluate your worth.
5. The button of taking things personally.
A comment about a project becomes a comment about your worth.
When one of these flares, you are not in your higher self.
You are in the acquired personality.
You have left the center and entered the battlefield.
The moment you notice this, the practice begins.
Presence: The Button Neutralizer
Presence does not suppress the reaction. It gives it space to unfold without taking over the system. As soon as you pause long enough to witness the reaction, you shift out of the personality that wants to defend itself and into the awareness that holds everything.
Try this:
Someone says something sharp. Before you respond, pause. Feel the contraction in your chest or stomach. Name it in neutral terms. “There’s the sting. There’s the defensiveness. There’s the rush of heat.”
Do not dramatize it. Do not judge it. Do not feed it.
Just feel it.
This brief moment of awareness disarms the hook. The energy loses its ability to hijack you. You are still in the situation, but you are no longer entangled in it.
This is the real inner alchemy.
Buttons dissolve in the light of attention.
The Freedom of Being Unhooked
When presence becomes your default instead of personality, something shifts at the deepest level of your being. People lose the ability to manipulate you. Situations lose the ability to dictate your mood. Even your own thoughts lose the power to derail your inner equilibrium.
Conversations become cleaner. Boundaries become clearer. Emotions become wiser.
You stop living inside a hall of mirrors and start living from the center.
You become less reactive and far more effective.
You move through life with the steadiness of someone who is not playing the same game as everyone else.
This is not emotional detachment. It is inner freedom.
You are not shutting down. You are showing up without being pulled apart.
Virgin Monk Boy’s Take
The ego is basically a pinball machine.
If someone hits the right pressure point, you light up, buzz, clatter, and send sparks everywhere.
The higher self is not a pinball machine.
There is nothing to hit. Nothing to trigger. Nothing to poke.
Most of the spiritual path is recognizing when your lights are flashing and choosing to step into the part of you that doesn’t need to react.
Blessed are the unbaited.
Blessed are the ones who can stay awake long enough to feel the hook without swallowing it.
Blessed are the ones who realize freedom is not the absence of emotion but the absence of reactivity.
Keep the Scrolls Unrolling
The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.
Share the Scrolls
Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.
Become a Supporting Member
Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.
Tip with a coffee
A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥
Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.
Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy
Recommended Reading
(As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. These recommendations support the scrolls at no extra cost to you.)
Many thanks for your great guidance to Presence. This “buttons” issue is one I’ve had trouble with, most of my life. There are a couple of people in my family who know my triggers & just love to jab me there (& a few who do it “unintentionally” but constantly). Learning to remember Presence at these times is a relief. Your lesson is a gift of freedom.⚡️
Just feel it. I can tell you’ve been practicing Buddhism from this “brief moment of awareness” practice alone. Beautiful post!