This reflection continues my series inspired by Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Discovering the Mind of Christ, Part 2, especially her commentaries on Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence. The first article looked at the Essential Self beneath personality. The second looked at the ego and its hilarious attempt to enlighten itself while still keeping the corner office. The third explored meditation through Thomas Keating’s image of boats floating down the river of consciousness. This reflection stays with that same river, but turns our attention to what happens after we’ve already climbed aboard one of those boats.
Most of us assume that is where we have failed.
Cynthia Bourgeault says it may be the moment when the deepest work has actually begun.
The Ego’s Definition of Progress
One of the students in Cynthia’s class describes an experience every contemplative eventually has. She realizes that she has been completely identified with her ego. She reacted unconsciously, became caught up in the situation, and only afterward recognized what had happened. Her conclusion is immediate and familiar.
“I saw it... but it was too late.”
That sentence contains almost everything the ego believes about the spiritual life.
The ego assumes progress means never becoming identified in the first place. It imagines that if we meditate long enough, pray hard enough, or become sufficiently enlightened, we will eventually eliminate all pride, fear, defensiveness, jealousy, and anger. Spiritual maturity becomes a kind of perfect emotional performance.
Helminski offers a very different picture. The work is not to become a person who never slips into identification. The work is to become someone who recognizes identification more quickly, more honestly, and with less self-deception.
That sounds like a small distinction.
It changes the entire journey.
“The Seeing Was the Doing”
Cynthia’s response to the student is one of the most striking moments in the course.
She simply says,
“The seeing was the doing.”
At first I resisted that statement. Surely seeing is only the beginning. Surely the real work is changing the behavior. If I become angry and only realize it afterward, haven’t I already failed?
But the longer I have sat with her words, the more profound they become.
A few moments earlier, the student was completely identified. The ego was driving the conversation, interpreting reality, and justifying every reaction. There was no space between awareness and experience.
Then something changed.
She saw.
That moment of seeing is not merely another thought floating through consciousness. It is consciousness waking up to itself. It is the moment awareness steps outside the machinery of identification and recognizes what has been happening.
The argument may already have occurred. The words cannot be taken back. But something infinitely more important has happened than simply winning the argument.
Awareness has appeared.
The False Self Cannot Expose Itself
One of Helminski’s central themes is that identification keeps us asleep. We become so fused with our thoughts, emotions, opinions, and roles that we no longer recognize them as passing experiences. We assume they are simply who we are.
Meditation begins loosening that fusion, not because thoughts disappear, but because awareness gradually stops disappearing into them.
This is why Cynthia places such importance on the moment of recognition.
If you suddenly notice that pride has taken over, who is doing the noticing?
If you become aware that resentment has been running your inner life for the past hour, what is it that has become aware?
The false self cannot expose itself in this way because, while it is operating, it is completely convinced that it is reality. It does not step outside itself to make objective observations. Something deeper has entered the picture.
The seeing itself is evidence that another center of consciousness has become active.
Why Shame Misses the Point
Unfortunately, the ego is remarkably adaptable.
The moment awareness appears, it often recruits that awareness into another story.
“I can’t believe I did that.”
“I’ve been meditating for years.”
“I should be beyond this by now.”
“I’ve failed again.”
Notice what has happened.
The original identification has dissolved, only to be replaced by identification with failure. Instead of becoming the angry person, we become the disappointed spiritual person. The costume changes, but the actor remains the same.
This is why shame has so little transforming power. Shame keeps our attention fixed on the ego. It asks us to evaluate our performance, measure our progress, and compare ourselves to some imaginary ideal. Even our disappointment becomes another form of self-occupation.
Awareness moves in the opposite direction. It is interested in seeing clearly, not in protecting an image of who we think we should be.
Thank You
This is why Cynthia recommends a response that initially sounds almost absurd.
Whenever you see another layer of identification...
Say, “Thank you.”
Not because the ego deserves congratulations.
Not because the behavior was healthy.
Not because we enjoy discovering our blind spots.
We say thank you because something that was previously hidden has just been revealed.
Imagine cleaning out an old attic. You pull away one dusty box and discover another corner of the room that has not seen daylight in decades. Your first response is not despair that the room was dirty. Your first response is gratitude that now you can finally see what was always there.
The contemplative life works in much the same way.
Every act of seeing enlarges the territory of freedom.
Every hidden attachment that comes into awareness loses some of its ability to control us unconsciously.
Every illusion exposed is one less illusion governing our lives from the shadows.
Measuring the Right Thing
Perhaps we have been measuring spiritual growth by the wrong standard.
We ask whether we became angry.
Whether we judged someone.
Whether we lost our patience.
Whether we managed to stay peaceful all day.
Those questions have their place, but Helminski’s teaching suggests another measure.
How quickly did awareness return?
Did you spend three days inside resentment before recognizing it?
Three hours?
Thirty minutes?
Thirty seconds?
Did you notice the tightening in your body before the words left your mouth?
Did you recognize the familiar pattern while it was still unfolding?
This is not a minor improvement in behavior. It is the gradual weakening of identification itself. Awareness becomes quicker than habit. Presence begins interrupting reactions that once operated entirely on their own.
That is real transformation.
Every Moment of Seeing Is Grace
The ego imagines the spiritual path as a long climb toward perfection.
The contemplative tradition describes something much humbler.
Again and again we fall asleep.
Again and again awareness returns.
Again and again another hidden attachment comes into the light.
If we meet those moments with shame, the ego simply finds another story to inhabit.
If we meet them with gratitude, awareness deepens.
Perhaps that is why Cynthia insists that the right response to every genuine moment of seeing is so wonderfully simple.
Thank you.
Not because the journey is finished.
But because, for one more moment, we were awake enough to see.
Keep the Scrolls Unrolling
The written publication is free for everyone to read.
Paid supporting members unlock the custom Virgin Monk Boy voiceover readings, the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and private chat perks like starting threads and sharing their own Substacks.
Share the Scrolls
Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.
Tip with a coffee
A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥
Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.
Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy
Recommended Reading
(As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. These recommendations support the scrolls at no extra cost to you.)
Living Presence: A Sufi Way to Mindfulness & the Essential Self by Kabir Helminski
This feels very close to dhikr for me. Not that I never forget, never react, never get swallowed by the nafs, but that I return. The seeing is mercy because it means some part of the heart is awake enough to notice what was hidden a moment ago.
I appreciate the simplicity of “thank you.” Shame would only give the ego another costume. But gratitude lets the seeing become part of the polishing. Thank you, Allah, that I saw it. Thank you that the reaction is not the whole of me. Thank you that return is still possible.
I adore this. As I move through healing and along a path of seeking. I still can get royally passed, annoyed, and selfish....but it doesn't take over my entire field of vision the way it used to. I have noticed that part, but adding in the thank you instead of judgement seems like a much more realistic way too move through life without spiritually gaslighting myself into denial! Thanks for this reminder. Saved to read on the days I forget. Haha. ❤️