This reflection is inspired by Through Holy Week with Mary Magdalene, guided by the teachings of Cynthia Bourgeault. In that series, Holy Week is not treated as a courtroom drama about guilt and acquittal, but as an initiation into conscious love. Not a trial. Not a settlement. An initiation. When Mary Magdalene is restored to her place at the foot of the cross, the meaning of crucifixion does not merely adjust. It stops behaving like bookkeeping. What had long been framed as cosmic accounting is exposed as love doing what love does when it is not interrupted.
Once that happens, the entire story tilts.
Not in doctrine first.
In tone.
Christianity begins to sound different. Less tight. Less afraid. Less obsessed with proving that God is justified in doing what God does. Love is no longer treated as a liability that must be hedged. It is allowed to stand there without apology.
Mary Magdalene does not merely alter interpretations.
She alters the weather.
A Pattern Hidden in Plain Sight
This isn’t a poetic claim. It’s a pattern, and it’s stubborn.
When Mary Magdalene is present, theology softens.
When she disappears, theology hardens.
That sentence is not decorative. It’s observable.
You can see it across doctrine, liturgy, preaching, iconography, spiritual practice, pastoral tone. When Mary Magdalene is allowed to remain visible, Christianity leans toward mercy, forgiveness, transformation, and love trusted to change what it touches. When she is erased, minimized, or “handled,” Christianity leans toward judgment, fear, debt, and surveillance.
The difference is not mainly doctrinal.
It’s not a checklist of beliefs.
It’s atmospheric.
Mary Magdalene functions less like a theological data point and more like a diagnostic instrument. She tells you what kind of God is being assumed long before anyone puts it into words.
Fear-Based Theology Cannot Tolerate Her
The harsher forms of atonement theology run on fear. They need it. A God who must be satisfied. A debt that must be paid. A sacrifice that balances the scales. Internally coherent systems, yes. Also emotionally brittle. They crack under pressure because they cannot tolerate love that is voluntary, excessive, or unregulated.
Mary Magdalene destabilizes them simply by being there.
She is not obedient in the way fear prefers.
She is not tidy.
She is not respectable.
She loves too much.
That is not a side note. That is the problem.
Fear-based theology works by managing desire. It decides which desires are safe, which are sinful, which must be amputated. It teaches that love has to be disciplined by fear or it will become dangerous. Mary Magdalene contradicts that whole operating system by embodying a love that is not corrected by fear but transformed by surrender.
She is not afraid enough to be useful.
“She Loved Much”: A Dangerous Sentence
One of the most revealing lines in the tradition is also one of the shortest. Jesus speaks of the woman who had been a sinner and says that she “loved much.”
Not that she feared much.
Not that she repented efficiently.
Not that she learned to hate herself correctly.
She loved much.
That sentence alone puts Mary Magdalene on a collision course with any theology that treats fear as spiritually productive. Love-based transformation and fear-based compliance cannot coexist peacefully. One always eats the other.
This is why early contemplative voices noticed something later theology worked hard to forget: eros is not the enemy of holiness. It is the raw material of it.
Mary Magdalene carries eros with her wherever she appears. Even when she is distorted into the repentant prostitute, even when she is misread, the heat remains. Desire does not vanish. It just refuses to behave.
And when eros is present, love cannot be reduced to obedience.
Love Has a Trajectory
One of the least tolerated ideas in Christian spirituality is that love itself changes. Not us loving better. Love itself. That it moves. That it matures. That it passes through loss and becomes something else without ceasing to be love.
Mary Magdalene stands right at that fault line.
She embodies love in motion.
Not love corrected.
Not love restrained.
Love that survives surrender.
That is why she appears so often in contemplative literature as a model rather than a warning. She does not demonstrate how to stop loving. She demonstrates how not to flee when love costs everything.
Most theology would rather not deal with that.
When love is treated as something dangerous, theology becomes defensive. It builds guardrails. It installs rules. When love is trusted to complete its own work, theology relaxes. It stops tightening its fists.
Mary Magdalene tells you which posture you are looking at.
Liturgy Tightens When She Leaves
The disappearance of Mary Magdalene from the center of Christian imagination coincides with a noticeable tightening of tone. Sin management moves forward. Moral accounting takes over. Juridical metaphors multiply.
This is not mysterious.
Mary Magdalene brings intimacy into theology. Intimacy is inefficient. It cannot be standardized. Institutions do not like it. Institutions prefer mechanisms. Mary Magdalene prefers presence.
When she is removed, the cross becomes easier to explain. It becomes a transaction. A requirement. A necessity.
When she is present, the cross becomes harder to live with. It stops solving a problem and starts exposing one. It shows what love looks like when it does not protect itself.
That is much harder to manage.
Iconography Knows What Doctrine Hides
Even when theology tried to discipline her, art kept giving her away.
Mary Magdalene is painted in red.
Her hair is loose.
Her grief is uncontained.
She does not look like someone who has resolved her moral issue. She looks like someone who stayed present to love when it hurt.
Icons remember what systems forget.
They preserve her as a sign that Christianity, when it is telling the truth, is not about fear finally being satisfied, but love refusing to leave. Even distorted depictions keep the signal alive. Wherever Mary Magdalene appears visually, the emotional temperature rises. Compassion enters. Judgment backs off.
She changes the weather even when misunderstood.
A Diagnostic Question
Mary Magdalene is not simply a figure in need of rehabilitation. She is a question Christianity keeps trying to step around.
Ask one thing of any theology:
Where is Mary Magdalene allowed to stand?
Near the center, where love is excessive and uncontrollable?
Or at the edges, where it can be explained away?
Is she treated as a witness to transformation?
Or an object lesson in shame?
Is her love trusted?
Or translated into fear before it is allowed to speak?
You already know the answers. You feel them before you articulate them.
Why She Softens Everything
Mary Magdalene softens Christianity’s tone because she refuses to let fear finish the story. She insists, by presence alone, that love is not a problem to be solved but a reality to be entered.
She stands at the cross not because she understands it, but because she does not leave. She stays through absence, through unknowing, through loss, without demanding a theory.
Fear needs clarity.
Love can live without it.
Mary Magdalene chooses love.
The Weather Vane Still Works
This pattern is not ancient history. It is active.
Where Mary Magdalene is reclaimed, Christianity becomes more human. More spacious. More honest about desire and grief and change. Where she is resisted, theology tightens, language sharpens, and fear quietly resumes control.
You can watch it happen.
Listen to how people talk about sin.
Listen to how they talk about the cross.
Listen to how they talk about love.
Then look for Mary Magdalene.
Her absence will explain everything.
Blessed are those who notice the shift in the air
and refuse to pretend the storm is holy.
Keep the Scrolls Unrolling
The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.
Share the Scrolls
Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.
Become a Supporting Member
Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.
Tip with a coffee
A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥
Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.
Thank you for articulating this truth. “eros is not the enemy of holiness.” I have often imagined what Mary went through at the foot of the cross. The moment Chrisianity has so often bypassed. She could have fought, hidden, started a vengeance movement, so many things. But she stayed. She witnessed through agony, and she remains today. This can only be the energy of love. Yes, the softness we ache for.
I would LOVE to forward this to this cousin ( whom I've mentioned before as an example of what I refer to as " toxic Evangelicals " ) who believes in fear - based closed - minded Christianity, but at best I'd get NO REACTION, & at worst, irrational, hysterical anger that I was " attacking her faith ".
Very good work !