🕊 Remorse Is the Portal, Not the Problem

Why spiritual awakening doesn’t begin with bliss—but with heartbreak.

Let’s just say it: the beginning of real transformation usually doesn’t look like enlightenment. It looks like heartbreak. It sounds like the quietest sob—"This can’t be it." And if you’ve ever heard that whispered ache inside yourself, not as a complaint but as a kind of homesick vow, you’re already closer to God than you think.

The mystics call it remorse, but don’t confuse that with guilt. Guilt is your ego throwing itself a pity party for being caught. Remorse is different. It’s not about what you did wrong. It’s about remembering who you really are—and aching because you’ve been living in exile from that self.

In Chapter Two of Living Presence, Kabir Helminski introduces a symbolic journey through the “City of Separation,” a world constructed by the ego and its compulsions. Cynthia Bourgeault, teaching through that map, pauses to clarify: this isn’t a neat staircase to enlightenment. It’s a wandering spiral of holy ache. It’s the aching that marks the beginning—not a polished life, not a perfect theology, not even a clear direction.

She reminds us: the ache itself is sacred.

When You Say, “This Can’t Be It”

That ache that says “This can’t be it” is not a flaw in your spiritual life—it’s the opening scene.

It’s what the ancient traditions described as remorse, but not in the shaming sense. Bourgeault makes this clear: “Remorse is a genuine starting point because it’s that great sense of aching that here is not home.” Whether it comes through disillusionment, burnout, or sheer holy boredom, remorse is the soul’s refusal to settle for less than reality.

William Styron once wrote, “Give me a new universe, Lord. This one isn’t large enough.”
That’s the prayer of remorse. And it’s answered not with escape—but with presence.

Guilt vs. Remorse

Guilt is always egoic. It’s performative. It’s about appearances and standards—either yours or someone else’s. Guilt keeps the false self intact while pretending it wants change. It’s cosmetic surgery for the conscience.

But remorse is quieter. Deeper. It’s the soul remembering its original brightness.

“Remorse doesn’t say, ‘I broke a rule.’ It says, ‘I’ve forgotten something sacred.’”
—Virgin Monk Boy

You can’t fake remorse. You also can’t force it. But when it comes, you’ll know. It sits behind the eyes, beneath the breath. It doesn’t beg to be seen—it just sits with you, heavy and holy.

Spiritual Nostalgia: A Feature, Not a Glitch

Sometimes that ache takes the form of divine homesickness—a word the Sufi lineage treats with care. Nostalgia for the Beloved is not sentimental; it’s cellular. Some people feel it as a memory they can’t trace, a longing for a presence they can’t name. Bourgeault recalls one woman in her workshop who wept because she “remembered” the taste of her soul’s homeland—and had no map to get back.

Virgin Monk Boy puts it in starker terms:

“You can take all the retreats you want, chant till your voice cracks, and visualize golden light in your root chakra—but if you’re not pierced by longing, you’re still decorating your prison cell.”

That longing isn’t dysfunction. It’s data. It’s how your soul knows it’s still alive. It’s the sign that your GPS is finally rerouting from enhancement to transformation.

Junk Food Spirituality and the City of Separation

Helminski’s “unreal city” isn’t just a symbol—it’s your curated feed. It’s the part of culture that offers spiritual cosmetics instead of depth. A course to “raise your frequency.” An influencer teaching “manifestation hacks.” The City of Separation isn’t overtly evil. It’s just hungry. And loud. And designed to keep you from hearing the subtle cry of the real.

Cynthia points out that in this city, many approach spirituality as a kind of inner lifestyle brand. Something to optimize. Something to “add to cart.”

But true inner work? It’s not additive. It’s subtractive. It melts you.

“Spirituality that never breaks your heart isn’t spiritual. It’s a feel-good holding pattern with incense.”
—Virgin Monk Boy

The Fog Is Holy Ground

What follows remorse isn’t always immediate clarity. Sometimes you just get fog. You don’t leap from remorse to revelation. You fumble. You wander. You cry out for a teacher. You try too hard. You doubt everything.

And that’s okay.

“The real spiritual journey is less like a staircase and more like circling a drain—with grace waiting at the bottom.”
—Virgin Monk Boy

Cynthia calls this phase “spiritual limbo,” and insists we not rush past it. She references St. Brendan, who wandered in mist for seven years before finding the Promised Land. Limbo isn’t a mistake. It’s fermentation. It’s how the old self begins to loosen. You’re not failing. You’re ripening.

Apprenticeship to Ache

The journey begins when we stop managing our symptoms and start listening to the ache. That ache is not a problem to be fixed—it’s the birthplace of true will.

As Bourgeault puts it, this whole journey is about discovering that the “essential self”—the part of you connected to God—is not something you build. It’s something you remember. But it only wakes up when the false self runs out of tricks.

The city falls. The ache rises. The real self hears the call.

And we begin.

Virgin Monk Boy’s Final Word:

Remorse isn’t weakness.
It’s sacred memory waking up.
It’s the soul whispering,
“You were made for more than inbox zero and intermittent fasting.”

So bless your ache.
Bless your divine homesickness.
Bless the tremble that says, “I remember.”

The City of Separation isn’t your tomb.
It’s your breadcrumb trail.

You’re not behind.
You’re not broken.
You’re just hearing the music again.

Follow the ache.
It’s how God calls you home.

—Virgin Monk Boy

🌀 Reflection Questions for Readers:

• When have you felt the ache that “this can’t be it”? What did it stir in you?

• Can you tell the difference in your body between guilt and remorse?

• Where do you feel divine homesickness in your life right now?

• Have you tried to skip the limbo phase—or can you bless it?

  ---

If this post unhinged your halo, poured some Presence in your posture, or made your inner heretic weep with joy—share it, toss a coin to your scribal renegade, or subscribe for more molten reflections from the margins.

Fuel the Jesus Wisdom Rebellion.