Breath as Second Being-Food: Why Spiritual Practice Begins with Breathing

Rediscovering Gurdjieff’s teaching and the wisdom hidden in chant.

⚠️ Spiritual Satire advisory: This essay contains equal parts mystical wisdom and burrito jokes. Proceed with lungs (and humor) open.

The Forgotten Breath

This reflection is inspired by Cynthia Bourgeault’s lecture series Through Holy Week with Mary Magdalene. Cynthia points to something we rarely notice: every authentic spiritual tradition treats the breath as sacred. Yogis have pranayama. Sufis have zikr. Buddhists have mindful breathing.

And Christianity? Believe it or not, we had our own version too. Not CrossFit. Not Wim Hof. Chant.

Gregorian chant wasn’t filler music before the sermon. It was spiritual breath-training with Latin subtitles—long, slow exhalations carried on tone. Monks spent hours every day stretching their breath across sacred syllables, building diaphragms stronger than their theology.

Modern science is finally catching up: lengthening the exhale stimulates the vagus nerve, calms the nervous system, and grounds the body. Monks didn’t have neuroscience, but they had chant—and it worked.

Which brings us to the mystic who explained why it worked: a mustached Armenian named George Ivanovich Gurdjieff.

Enter Gurdjieff, the Dinner Guest You Can’t Pronounce

George Ivanovich Gurdjieff. Yes, it sounds like someone sneezed in Russian. He was an early 20th-century mystic who made even the most hardcore monks look like part-time hobbyists. His main thesis: humans are basically sleepwalking meat robots who need to wake up.

And his spiciest idea? We survive on three foods. Not just bread and wine, but a whole esoteric buffet.

• Food for the body. Obvious. You chew it, you swallow it, and hope your metabolism is still taking calls. Burritos, brisket, leftover pizza at 2 a.m.—aka the holy trinity of regret. Keeps you alive, but it won’t make you a morning person. Not even waffles can do that.

• Air for the being. The breath itself. Second being-food. You can go three weeks without eating, three days without water, but three minutes without air and you’re auditioning for CSI. Yet most of us breathe like raccoons caught rifling through a trash can—short, shallow, panicked. Gurdjieff said conscious breathing doesn’t just keep you alive; it actually feeds your inner life. Breathe shallow, live shallow.

• Impressions for the soul. This is everything that enters through your senses: sunsets, memes, the smell of coffee, Fox News chyrons (handle with care). Your soul digests impressions the same way your gut digests food. Some nourish, some poison, most just pass through unnoticed. Question isn’t if you’re eating impressions—it’s whether you’re dining on sacred poetry or doomscrolling junk food.

Miss one of these and you don’t just get hungry—you lose vitality. It’s like being a plant that gets watered but never sees the sun. You survive, but you do it in beige.

Imagine this: you’re at a five-course dinner. Filet mignon, wine, dessert. But while chewing, you’re also holding your breath, and while holding your breath, you’re doomscrolling celebrity divorces. That’s us. Full bellies, starved lungs, poisoned souls. Spiritual malnutrition with free refills.

Cynthia’s Mic Drop

This is where Cynthia Bourgeault throws down. In her Magdalene lectures, she points out that Christianity once knew how to feed the “air” and “impressions” levels—through chant. Monks weren’t mumbling in Latin to impress God. They were biohacking before Silicon Valley was born.

Hours of chant each day: inhale two counts, exhale seven. Over and over. A nervous system spa day, every day.

But then we swapped it for campfire choruses. “Kyrie Eleison” became “Jesus Loves Me This I know, cause the Bible tells me so,” and just like that, a thousand years of embodied breath practice left the building.

The Western Breath Crisis

Fast forward to now. A civilization that forgot its chant, misplaced its lungs, and decided shallow breathing was normal.

Look around:

• At work, people hunched over laptops, holding their breath like they’re trying to sneak past a T-Rex.

• In traffic, exhaling only to scream at the car in front.

• On TikTok, gasping at a 20-second video of a cat playing piano.

Science confirms what monks already knew: short, jerky breaths put your body in panic mode. Long, steady breaths calm the system down. Translation: your lungs are either your therapist or your arsonist.

Chant as Hidden Yoga

Picture a monk in the choir stall. He inhales, then releases Kyrie eleison—a long, flowing tone stretched across seven beats. His whole body is an instrument of breath. After a few hours, he’s basically doing yoga with a soundtrack.

Now picture modern worship: a praise band on stage. Everyone singing in short bursts: “Jesus loves me, this I know…” Breath in, breath out, like a spiritual hiccup. The song ends, but the nervous system is exactly where it started—frazzled.

Chant was Christianity’s pranayama. When we lost it, we didn’t just lose solemnity. We lost our lungs.

Why the False Self Hates Deep Breathing

The false self—your anxious, dramatic, over-caffeinated alter ego—cannot survive long stretches of conscious breath. It feeds on hiccups and pauses, not flow.

Hold your breath and suddenly you’re flooded with thoughts: “What if they don’t like me?” “What if I die alone?” “What if Costco runs out of free samples?”

But keep the breath steady—in, out, no pause—and the ego loses its power source. The mask slips. Presence takes over. The false self can’t monologue if you cut its mic.

That’s why yogis, monks, and Sufi chanters all end up suspiciously chill in the same way. Long breath = quiet ego.

Practical Entry Points: Feeding Your Being

Breath is the most democratic spiritual practice. No subscription fee. No shipping delays. Just lungs.

Try one of these:

1. The Fifteen-Minute Sit.
   Sit down. Breathe in, breathe out. Don’t pause. No need to force it—your lungs know the drill. Fifteen minutes and you’ve recharged your spiritual Wi-Fi.

2. Chant as Breath Practice.
   Pick a word. Any word. Kyrie eleison. Alleluia. Even Ommm-tacos. Inhale gently, then let the word ride your exhale until the breath runs out. Congratulations: you’re a monk, minus the haircut.

3. Walking with Breath.
   Hate sitting still? Walk. Three steps inhale, four steps exhale. Keep going until you notice your body isn’t just moving—it’s praying.

Takeaway

The beginning of the spiritual path isn’t in your head. You don’t argue your way into awakening. You don’t binge-watch your way into transformation. You breathe.

Gurdjieff said it. Cynthia reminded us. Monks lived it. Breath is second being-food. And most of us are starving.

For Further Practice

If this reflection stirred something in you, here are a couple of doorways worth opening:

• Cynthia Bourgeault, Through Holy Week with Mary Magdalene — the lecture series that sparked this very post. Cynthia traces how breath, chant, and embodied practice open us to the Paschal mystery.

• Jean-Yves Leloup, The Gospel of Thomas — Leloup’s contemplative translation and commentary on one of the earliest Christian wisdom texts. Many of its sayings point directly to breath and presence:

  • Saying 50: “If they say to you, ‘Where did you come from?’ say to them, ‘We came from the light, the place where the light came into being of itself…’” Leloup notes this as a call to remember the breath of origin—the “light” inhaled with every moment of awareness.

  • Saying 111: “The heavens and the earth will roll up in your presence, and the living one who comes from the living one will not see death.” Breath is the bridge to that presence—the way the temporal folds into the eternal with each inhale and exhale.

• Your own lungs. Before you buy another book, sit down and breathe. Inhale, exhale, no pause. Feed the being.

  ---

✦ Before You Slip Back Into the Illusion ✦

If this stirred something in you—if it poked that holy ache or reminded you that your life is more than autopilot—don’t just click away. Tap the like or share button like you’re hammering another brick into your soul’s foundation.

And if you want to keep walking this path with me, consider a paid subscription or even a one-time donation. It keeps the scrolls unrolling, the incense smoldering, and the Magdalene movement caffeinated. ☕🔥