The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls: Wisdom Jesus

Why Daydreaming Isn’t the Creative Genius You Think It Is

Virgin Monk Boy — Sat, 16 May 2026 12:50:14 GMT

This reflection grows out of the same stream as Real Will Isn’t Willpower and Presence Changes the Room: Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, read through Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence, with that stubborn little Sufi-Christian insistence that attention is not just something we “pay” when life gets interesting. Attention is energy. Attention is freedom. Attention is how we stop being dragged around by every shiny object, old wound, private fantasy, and imaginary argument with someone named Gary who has never met a comment section he could not spiritually pollute.

Most of us have been taught to romanticize the wandering mind. Daydreaming gets treated like the sacred birthplace of creativity, as if every time we mentally leave the room, a muse appears with a clipboard and a publishing contract. But this chapter makes a sharper distinction. The mind drifting into fantasy is not the same as the heart opening into the imaginal. One is often escape dressed up as inspiration. The other comes through presence, through voluntary attention, through being awake enough to receive what is actually trying to arrive. Fantasy lets us leave life. The imaginal asks us to enter it more deeply.

Subscribe now

We have made daydreaming sound much holier than it is.

Somewhere along the way, zoning out got rebranded as creativity. Staring into space became “letting the mind wander.” Losing fifteen minutes to an imaginary argument with someone who annoyed us in 2018 became “processing.” Mentally redecorating our life while ignoring the actual life in front of us became “visioning.”

Very impressive. The ego got a Canva account and called itself a muse.

Now, to be fair, not every wandering thought is useless. The mind does have a hidden life. Images rise. Connections form. Problems sometimes solve themselves after we stop trying to strangle them with our forehead. Anyone who has written, painted, preached, taught, gardened, parented, or survived a committee meeting with Episcopalians knows that insight often arrives sideways.

But the inner tradition makes a sharp distinction that our culture mostly blurs: spacing out is not the same as inspiration.

Daydreaming is not the same as the imaginal.

One is psychic leakage. The other is a doorway.

And the difference is presence.

The Cult of the Wandering Mind

Modern culture loves the wandering mind because modern culture is exhausted.

We are overloaded, over-notified, over-managed, over-caffeinated, and under-present. So when the mind finally floats away from the spreadsheet, the sermon, the inbox, or the comment thread, we mistake that escape hatch for freedom.

Of course daydreaming feels good. It asks almost nothing of us. It lets us leave the room without the inconvenience of actually moving our body. It gives us a private Netflix series starring ourselves as the misunderstood genius, the devastatingly articulate comeback artist, the beloved mystic, the successful author, the person whose enemies finally realize they were wrong and send a formal apology basket.

And honestly, who among us has not enjoyed a little fantasy litigation in the courthouse of the mind?

But most daydreaming is not creative. It is reactive.

It is attention that got grabbed and then wandered into the basement wearing socks on a wet floor.

The chapter’s teaching is blunt about this. Attention can be caught by something that attracts or repulses us. A like. A dislike. A desire. A fear. A little wound with Wi-Fi. Once attention is caught, it often slides into commentary, fantasy, identification, and daydreaming. That is not the awakened self creating. That is the ego burning incense in front of its own slideshow.

Sensitive Energy Is Not Consciousness

Here is where the teaching gets useful.

There is a kind of attention that becomes intensely absorbed in an object. You are playing music, writing, scrolling, fantasizing, flirting, building your imaginary TED Talk, or mentally winning an argument with Pastor Chad from the Church of Lightly Baptized Rage. You are absorbed. You may even feel energized.

But absorbed does not always mean awake.

This is what the teaching calls bound attention. The object has captured you. You are “in it,” but you are not free in it. There is no spacious awareness. No watcher. No deep “I am here.” The attention has been consumed by the thing it notices.

That can happen in beautiful ways. A pianist lost in Beethoven. A gardener lost in roses. A writer lost in a sentence.

It can also happen in ridiculous ways. A grown adult losing twenty minutes imagining the perfect reply to a Facebook comment written by someone named Gary who thinks “research” means watching a man yell in his truck.

Either way, the issue is the same. The attention has been bound.

And the inner path is not trying to make us more absorbed. It is trying to make us more present.

The Imaginal Is Not Fantasy With Better Lighting

This is the distinction that matters.

Fantasy is usually built from the ego’s leftovers. It rearranges old fears, desires, wounds, ambitions, grudges, and cravings into little mental movies. It may look creative, but often it is just the nervous system wearing a director’s beret.

The imaginal is different.

The imaginal is not escapism. It is a deeper mode of perception. It rises from presence, not avoidance. It comes when the mind is not rigidly forcing an answer, but also not wandering off into psychic fog. It comes when attention is gathered enough to be receptive.

That is why meditation, contemplative prayer, dhikr, chanting, walking prayer, and deep silence often produce better insight than daydreaming. Not because the ego finally “figured it out,” but because the ego stopped hogging the microphone.

You sit. You return. You breathe. You notice the thought, release the thought, come back to presence. You stop trying to milk the universe like a content cow. Then, half an hour later, while making tea or staring at the wall or opening the laptop, the sentence comes. The answer comes. The image comes. Not because you went out to lunch, but because you came home.

The imaginal does not require unconsciousness.

It requires availability.

Presence Is Not Trying Harder

This is where people get nervous.

Because once we say daydreaming is not the same as inspiration, someone immediately hears, “Great, so I’m supposed to clench my mind like a spiritual accountant and never relax.”

No.

That is not presence. That is the ego wearing a tight little meditation helmet.

Presence is not grim concentration. It is not staring at your toothbrush like it owes you money. It is not turning every ordinary task into a Navy SEAL operation for mindfulness. “I will now brush tooth number fourteen with pure nondual awareness.” Congratulations, Brother Plaque Removal, you have made enlightenment unbearable.

The teaching points to something subtler: double awareness.

You are aware of the object and the subject. The ship and the river. The task and the one doing the task. The sentence and the spaciousness from which the sentence appears.

You are not lost in the piano. You are here, playing the piano.

You are not lost in the thought. You are here, noticing thought.

You are not lost in the fantasy. You are here, seeing the fantasy arise, perform its tiny community theater production, and dissolve.

That small shift changes everything.

Creativity Needs a Vessel

The modern creative myth says, “Let yourself wander and see what happens.”

The inner tradition says, “Become present enough to receive what is real.”

That second path is less glamorous because it does not flatter the ego. It does not treat every mental squiggle as genius. It does not call every distraction a download.

Some thoughts are not downloads. Some are just pop-ups from the basement.

True inspiration needs a vessel. Presence is the vessel.

A scattered mind may produce cleverness. A restless mind may produce novelty. A wounded mind may produce intensity. But presence gives creativity depth. It lets the image come from somewhere truer than personal anxiety. It allows the work to carry being, not just noise.

This is why some writing feels technically polished but spiritually empty. The sentences are dressed nicely, but no one is home. Meanwhile, another piece may be simple, even plain, but it has weight. It has silence inside it. It came through someone who was actually there.

The imaginal is not just “making stuff up.”

It is seeing from the heart.

Don’t Beat Yourself Up. Just Wake Up.

Of course you will daydream.

You are human. Your mind has been trained by a civilization that makes billions of dollars by stealing attention, scattering it, and selling it back to you as lifestyle optimization. So yes, sometimes your mind is going to wander off and build a beach house in the astral suburbs.

Do not turn that into shame.

Shame is just another form of identification. Now instead of daydreaming, you are daydreaming about being a bad spiritual practitioner. Very advanced. The monastery of self-criticism has excellent acoustics and terrible snacks.

The practice is simpler.

Notice.

Where did attention go?

What grabbed it?

Was it fear? Desire? Boredom? Resentment? The need to be seen? The need to be right? The hope that one day your enemies will gather in a circle and chant, “You were correct, O luminous one”?

Just notice.

That noticing is already the beginning of freedom.

A Small Practice for the Imaginal

Try this before writing, creating, praying, or making any decision that matters.

Sit for five minutes. No drama. No incense required, though incense does help if your room smells like laundry regret.

Feel your body.

Let the breath come and go.

When thoughts arise, do not chase them and do not fight them. Notice them. Release them. Return.

Then ask inwardly: What wants to come through that is not just my anxiety talking?

Do not force an answer.

Stay present.

Then write, draw, speak, pray, or move.

The goal is not to empty the mind into a sterile waiting room. The goal is to become available to a deeper intelligence than the one that makes grocery lists and rehearses imaginary arguments in the shower.

The imaginal does not shout over the noise.

It waits beneath it.

The Real Muse Is Presence

Daydreaming may give you material. Presence gives you meaning.

Daydreaming may entertain the ego. Presence opens the heart.

Daydreaming may produce a clever idea. Presence can bring forth something that carries life.

So yes, let the mind rest. Let it soften. Let it stop grinding like a Protestant work ethic with a ring light. But do not confuse psychic drift with sacred imagination.

The real muse does not usually arrive when we are spacing out.

She arrives when we are finally here.

May your fantasies lose their management position.

May your attention come home without filing a complaint.

May the imaginal rise from the heart like a candle in a quiet room.

And may your next good idea not come from escaping your life, but from entering it more deeply.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Presence Changes the Room

Virgin Monk Boy — Sun, 10 May 2026 14:48:30 GMT

Attention Is Not Just Personal

This reflection grows out of the same stream as Real Will Isn’t Willpower: Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Practicing Living Presence, Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, read through Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence, with that stubborn little Sufi-Christian insistence that attention is not just a private spiritual trick we perform inside our skulls. Attention is energetic. Presence has weight. Being fully here does not merely change how we feel about a situation. It can change the situation itself. Which sounds a little mystical until you have been in a room where one grounded person walks in and suddenly the emotional furniture stops flying.

Most of us think presence is personal. I am present. I am calm. I am centered. I am having a spiritual moment while everyone else is out here acting like raccoons trapped in a church basement. But the deeper teaching is more unsettling and more beautiful than that. Presence is not a decorative inner mood. It is not the scented candle version of consciousness. It is a field.

And fields affect things.

Subscribe now

Every Room Has Weather

We already know this in ordinary life. Walk into a room where everyone is anxious, and your body knows it before your mind starts taking notes. The shoulders tighten. The breath rises. The room has a weather system. No one has to announce, “Welcome to today’s group panic spiral.” You just feel the psychic humidity and begin sweating through your soul.

The same thing happens in reverse. Someone deeply present enters, and the room begins to remember itself. Not because they dominate it. Not because they perform holiness. Not because they start using that calm therapist voice that makes you want to commit light vandalism. Something in them is simply not scattered. Their attention is gathered. Their being is not leaking into every passing irritation, preference, fear, and performance cue. They are here.

And here is contagious.

Presence Is Not Control

That is the hidden power in this teaching on voluntary attention. Attention is not merely the ability to stare really hard at one object like a monk trying to win a staring contest with a carrot. Attention, when joined to surrender, becomes a way of being available to reality without being eaten by it. You can be aware of what is happening outside you and aware of the one inside you who is seeing. You can hold both the river and the ships passing over it. That is the beginning of freedom.

It is also the beginning of a different kind of power.

Not power over people. God save us from one more spiritual person who discovers “energy” and immediately becomes a tiny cult leader with essential oils and boundary issues. This is not domination. This is not psychic control. This is not walking into Thanksgiving dinner and silently commanding Uncle Gary to stop explaining economics he learned from a meme. Though honestly, we understand the temptation.

This power is quieter than that. It is the power of non-reactive being. The power of not joining the room’s unconscious agreement to become frantic. The power of not feeding the fire just because everyone else is tossing in furniture and calling it authenticity.

The Airport Becomes a Chapel

One of the examples from the teaching is almost absurdly ordinary. A person is sitting in an airport, waiting for a flight. A pilot is on the phone. A couple of men are nearby. Nothing dramatic is happening. No choir descends from the ceiling. No stained glass appears in Terminal B. But suddenly there is stillness. A felt sense of connection. The person sitting there experiences that the stillness is not merely inside them. It is between them. It is being sustained in the room, or the waiting area, or whatever sacred architectural wonder airport designers created after apparently losing a bet with fluorescent lighting.

That is presence changing the room.

And notice where it happens. Not in a monastery. Not during an ordination. Not at the perfect retreat center where everyone is wearing linen and pretending they don’t judge the coffee. It happens in an airport. The modern temple of delay, irritation, boarding group hierarchy, and overpriced sandwiches. If presence can happen there, it can happen anywhere.

Sacred Space Is Made by Being

This matters because most people are still carrying around a childish idea of sacred space. We think sacred space is something already prepared for us. A chapel. A shrine. A retreat center. A candlelit room. A place with cushions and a person named River who tells you where to put your shoes. And yes, spaces can be prepared. Beauty helps. Silence helps. Ritual helps. But sacred space is not finally created by objects. It is created by quality of being.

The room becomes sacred when someone is actually there.

The Toilet Brush as Spiritual Director

This is why the priest cleaning toilets matters so much.

In the teaching, there is an example of an Anglican priest cleaning toilets at Glen Airley and coming out radiant. Not because toilets are glamorous. Let us not spiritually gaslight the plumbing. Cleaning toilets is cleaning toilets. It is not secretly a luxury spa treatment for the soul. But she discovered something that most of us miss because we are too busy dragging our precious identity behind us like a designer suitcase full of grievances. She realized this task did not demean her priesthood. It gave her a place to put her attention completely in the present.

That is the whole sermon right there.

The ego says, “This is beneath me.” Presence says, “This is what is here.”

The ego says, “I should be doing something more important.” Presence says, “Importance is often just vanity wearing a nicer jacket.”

The ego says, “I am a priest, a teacher, a writer, a professional, a person with a LinkedIn profile and carefully curated suffering.” Presence says, “Yes, beloved, and the toilet is still dirty.”

There is something wonderfully humiliating about real spiritual practice. It keeps refusing to respect the hierarchy our ego built to protect itself. We want our transformation to happen through meaningful conversations, powerful visions, perfect liturgy, deep books, and maybe a dramatic tear rolling down one cheek while Rumi is quoted responsibly for once. But then the path hands us a toilet brush.

Not as punishment. As mercy.

Because the toilet brush reveals the truth. Can you be here when no one is impressed? Can you give yourself fully to the task that does not flatter your identity? Can you bring attention to the thing your personality would rather outsource to someone less spiritually significant?

This is where sacred space begins. Not with incense. With undivided attention.

One Present Person Gives the Room Another Option

And this is also where group dynamics begin to shift. A group is not just a collection of opinions. A group is an energetic system. If one person is frantic, that franticness recruits others. If one person is offended, the room starts looking for teams. If one person is performing intelligence, suddenly half the room is tightening its vocabulary and pretending to understand words it plans to Google later.

But if one person is present, genuinely present, not frozen, not detached in that dead-eyed “I have transcended you peasants” way, but alive, spacious, awake, something else becomes possible. The room has another option.

This is why sustained attention matters. A flash of presence is beautiful, but sustained attention becomes shelter. It gives the group a center of gravity that is not built from fear. It allows people to stop being yanked around by every like and dislike, every emotional gust, every little ego mosquito whining, “What about me? What about me? What about me?”

Stop Donating Your Unconsciousness to the Room

Presence does not erase conflict. It does not turn difficult people into forest animals who gather peacefully around your aura. Some people will remain committed to being difficult with the devotion of medieval monks copying manuscripts. But presence changes your participation in the conflict. You stop donating your unconsciousness to the group account.

That alone matters.

Scattered Attention Drains the Soul

The teaching makes a strong claim: when our attention is dissipated, part of us is already in the past or future, and that drains us. Anyone who has survived a day of meetings knows this in the bones. You are in one conversation while rehearsing the next one, resenting the previous one, silently editing the email you should have sent, and wondering whether the person across from you has always chewed that loudly or whether God is testing your commitment to compassion.

By the end of the day, you are exhausted, not because you did so much, but because you were divided through all of it.

Presence gathers the scattered pieces.

Presence Makes Action Cleaner

This does not mean you become slow, precious, or useless. Presence is not spiritual molasses. It is not whispering while the building burns. In fact, real presence often makes action cleaner and quicker because you are not dragging your entire psychological junk drawer into the moment. You see more. You react less. You respond from a deeper place.

A present person can act firmly without adding violence to the atmosphere. A present person can speak truth without needing the ego dessert of superiority. A present person can clean the toilet, sit in the airport, lead the meeting, hold the grief, walk into the tense room, and quietly refuse to feed the collective possession.

This is sacred work.

Not flashy. Not marketable. Hard to put on a conference banner. “Come learn how to stand still inside yourself while everyone else emotionally cannonballs into the kiddie pool.” Probably not selling out the arena. But it might save your soul. And on a good day, it might save the room.

The hidden power of being fully here is that reality recognizes itself through us. When we are scattered, the world becomes more scattered through us. When we are reactive, the world becomes more reactive through us. When we are present, even briefly, even clumsily, even while holding a toilet brush or waiting for a delayed flight next to a man loudly explaining speakerphone technology to the entire airport, something else enters the field.

A little more space.

A little more mercy.

A little more room for God to breathe.

The Practice Is Not to Make the Room Worse

And maybe that is enough for one day’s practice. Not to become impressive. Not to radiate saintly vibes like a spiritual space heater. Just to enter one ordinary room today and not make it worse. To bring one gathered breath. One unscattered glance. One moment of attention that is not for sale to every passing irritation.

May we become the kind of people whose presence gives the room permission to remember its own soul.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Real Will Isn’t Willpower

Virgin Monk Boy — Tue, 05 May 2026 12:03:18 GMT

Acting From the Center Instead of the Script

This reflection grows out of Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Practicing Living Presence, read through Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence, and that whole stubborn Sufi insistence that attention is not just something the mind does when it behaves itself. Attention is the hinge between compulsion and freedom. It is the small inner faculty by which a human being begins to stop being dragged around by every impulse, wound, preference, fantasy, irritation, and shiny little emotional object waving from the side of the road.

That matters because most of us confuse will with force. We think we have strong will because we can push harder, clench tighter, work longer, argue louder, resist better, and keep performing our favorite identity even when it is clearly smoking from the engine. But in this tradition, real will is not the same thing as willpower. Willpower can still belong entirely to the ego. Real will begins when attention becomes free enough to choose from the center instead of reacting from the script.

Subscribe now

The Script Wearing Your Face

Every person has a script. Some of it came from family. Some came from religion. Some came from culture, trauma, school, shame, praise, disappointment, survival, and that one adult who probably should not have been allowed within twenty feet of a developing nervous system.

The script tells us what kind of person we are supposed to be. The responsible one. The rebel. The fixer. The helper. The impressive one. The victim. The genius nobody understands. The spiritual person who is very detached except when someone loads the dishwasher incorrectly, at which point the entire monastery becomes unsafe.

The problem is not that these scripts exist. The problem is that we mistake them for ourselves.

A script can be useful. A personality can help us function in the world. Somebody has to answer the email, pay the electric bill, make dinner, and act like a grown-up at the DMV even when the soul is quietly composing a lamentation. The ego has its place. The personality has its place. The script can even get us through some very difficult rooms.

But the script is not the center.

When the script is running the show, life becomes reactive. We are no longer responding to what is actually happening. We are responding to what the moment resembles. Someone says something with a certain tone, and suddenly we are not in the present conversation. We are twelve years old again, or twenty-five, or back in some argument from 2014 where we finally know what we should have said.

Bless the little time-traveling ego. It has never met a present moment it could not contaminate with archival footage.

Willfulness Loves a Costume

Willfulness is sneaky because it often dresses itself as strength. It says, “I know what I want.” It says, “I am standing my ground.” It says, “This is just who I am.” Sometimes it even says, “God told me,” which is usually the moment everyone should hide the matches.

Willfulness is the ego’s attempt to control reality from the outside. It tries to force an outcome, defend an identity, protect an old wound, or impose an inner preference on the situation in front of it. It may look disciplined. It may look passionate. It may look morally serious. But underneath, it is usually tied to like and dislike, praise and blame, approval and disapproval.

That is the giveaway.

If something in us is being yanked around by whether we are admired, agreed with, validated, obeyed, understood, liked, respected, feared, or proven right, then we are probably not operating from real will. We are operating from the script, even if the script has a spiritual vocabulary and owns linen.

This is why Helminski’s teaching on attention gets so uncomfortable. He does not let us pretend that every strong inner movement is freedom. Much of what we call choice is simply compulsion with a better publicist.

The ego says, “I chose this.”

The deeper work asks, “Did you choose it, or did your conditioning choose it before you even arrived?”

Rude question. Necessary question.

Real Will Begins With Seeing

Real will does not begin by forcing ourselves to be better. It begins by seeing more clearly.

That is less glamorous than the ego prefers. The ego would like transformation to involve thunder, initiation, a robe, maybe a raven, possibly a secret name whispered by a suspiciously attractive desert elder. But the work usually begins in a much smaller place.

You notice the impulse.

That is it.

You notice the urge to interrupt. You notice the need to win. You notice the collapse when someone criticizes you. You notice the inflation when someone praises you. You notice the body tightening before the mind has built its case. You notice the familiar inner lawyer rolling up with exhibits, expert witnesses, and a PowerPoint titled “Why I Am Absolutely Correct and Everyone Else Needs Inner Work.”

That noticing is not nothing. It is the first movement of freedom.

Because until you notice the impulse, you are the impulse. Until you notice the script, you are inside the script. Until you see the machinery, you keep calling the machinery “me.”

Voluntary attention is the act of turning toward what is happening without immediately being swallowed by it. It allows something in us to stand half an inch back from the reaction. Not above it in some superior spiritual balcony. Just slightly free of it.

That half inch is where real will is born.

The Pause Is Not Passive

There is a moment between being triggered and obeying the trigger. It may be very small. At first, it may be so small that you only notice it three hours later while eating crackers over the sink and replaying the entire incident with the emotional restraint of a cable news panel.

Still counts.

Eventually, with practice, you begin to catch it sooner. Maybe twenty minutes later. Then five minutes later. Then in the middle of the reaction. Then, once in a while, right at the edge, before the old thing takes the wheel.

That pause is not passivity. It is not weakness. It is not becoming a spiritual doormat with a scented candle. It is the gathering of attention before action.

Sometimes the centered response is silence. Sometimes it is a clear no. Sometimes it is leaving the room. Sometimes it is speaking with more force than the personality would have dared, but without the inner violence that usually comes along for the ride.

Presence does not make us limp. It makes us less hijackable.

Jesus flipping tables is not the same thing as someone having a tantrum because the church coffee was weak. Force can come from clarity. Anger can also come from egoic possession. The outer shape may look similar for a second, but the inner source is completely different.

One acts from the center.

The other acts from the wound and then asks theology to notarize it.

Willpower Tries to Win. Real Will Tries to Serve.

Willpower is often concerned with victory. It wants to overcome the obstacle, conquer the desire, defeat the weakness, master the habit, dominate the room, and prove the self. There can be usefulness in that at a certain level. Sometimes we do need effort. Sometimes we do need discipline. Sometimes the laundry does not care about our mystical process and would simply like to be moved from the washer before it becomes a swamp relic.

But real will serves something deeper than self-conquest.

Real will asks, “What is needed here?”

Not, “What do I prefer?”

Not, “What protects my image?”

Not, “What lets me keep telling the same story about myself?”

What is needed here?

That question changes the inner atmosphere. It moves us from reaction to participation. It places us under something larger than the ego’s immediate weather system. The center does not ask how to preserve the script. It asks how to align with reality.

And reality is often deeply annoying.

Reality may ask us to apologize when the ego had a whole courtroom drama prepared. Reality may ask us to speak when the script prefers hiding. Reality may ask us to rest when willpower wants another medal for self-abandonment. Reality may ask us to stop helping because our “help” has become control wearing a cardigan.

Real will has a flexibility that willfulness does not have. It can move. It can wait. It can act. It can yield. It can say yes without grasping and no without hatred.

The script cannot do that. The script only knows its lines.

Freedom Is Not Doing Whatever You Want

Modern culture has trained us to think freedom means unlimited preference. Choose your brand. Choose your identity. Choose your aesthetic. Choose your outrage package. Customize the cage until it looks like self-expression.

But the inner traditions are deeply suspicious of this kind of freedom. They know that most of what we call “what I want” is just conditioning with a microphone.

The person who cannot resist an impulse is not free. The person who must respond to every insult is not free. The person who needs constant approval is not free. The person who has to be seen as good, wise, correct, edgy, spiritual, persecuted, enlightened, or right on schedule with their healing journey is not free.

Freedom begins when attention is no longer automatically captured by attraction and aversion.

This does not mean preferences disappear. You can still prefer coffee over tea, silence over noise, good bread over whatever that communion wafer situation is trying to be. The point is not to become blank. The point is to stop letting preference rule the soul.

You may dislike the task and still give yourself to it.

You may feel irritation and still not become irritation.

You may want to flee and still remain present.

That is not repression. That is the beginning of inner strength.

The Center Is Quieter Than the Script

The script is usually dramatic. It explains itself constantly. It has reasons, grievances, slogans, costumes, and a full emotional soundtrack.

The center is quieter.

It does not need to announce itself as much because it is not trying to become real through performance. It is already rooted somewhere deeper than approval or defense. When we act from the center, there is often a sense of right proportion. The action may be small or large, gentle or fierce, but it does not have the same frantic taste.

That taste matters.

This is one of the practical gifts of inner work. Over time, we begin to recognize the flavor of our own states. We know what it tastes like to be reactive. We know what it tastes like to be hooked. We know what it tastes like when the ego is pretending to be discernment but is really just wearing judge robes over a panic attack.

And we begin to know, even if only for brief moments, what it tastes like to be present.

More spacious. More grounded. Less sticky. Less performative. Less desperate to secure the self through the next sentence.

This is not perfection. This is orientation.

The center becomes easier to find because we have visited it before.

The Practice Is Right Here

The training ground for real will is not somewhere else. It is not waiting for retreat conditions, better candles, more silence, or a personality transplant.

It is in the next ordinary moment.

When the phone buzzes, pause before reaching.

When irritation rises, feel it before speaking.

When praise lands, notice the little inflation balloon.

When criticism lands, notice the collapse, the defense, the counterattack forming in the basement.

When you are halfway through brushing your teeth and realize you have mentally left the room to rehearse a speech no one asked for, come back.

Not with violence. Not with shame. Not with the spiritual hall monitor blowing a whistle.

Just return.

Every return strengthens the faculty that can choose. Every return weakens the automatic script. Every return gives real will a little more room to breathe.

And eventually, something in us starts to understand that freedom is not a mood. It is not a personality trait. It is not the ability to force life into submission.

Freedom is the capacity to remain inwardly available enough to respond from the center.

Blessed be the pause that interrupts the old performance.

Blessed be the breath before the reaction.

Blessed be the moment when the ego reaches for the steering wheel and something deeper says, “Not this time, little chaos goblin.”

And blessed be real will, quiet and steady, rising from the center, teaching us that we were never meant to live as puppets of our own conditioning.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

How to Watch Yourself Slip Out the Back Door

Virgin Monk Boy — Mon, 13 Apr 2026 12:03:23 GMT

This reflection grows out of the same stream as You Don’t Have to Like It to Pay Attention: Cynthia Bourgeault’s work with Practicing Living Presence, read through Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence, and that whole stubborn Sufi insistence that attention is not just a mental function but a spiritual hinge. One of the things that becomes painfully obvious once you begin trying to practice this in ordinary life is that most of us do not lose presence in grand moral crises. We lose it in the bathroom, in the grocery store, in the car, in the ten seconds between one task and the next. The soul does not usually leak out through some dramatic wound. It slips quietly out the back door while we are brushing our teeth and thinking about revenge.

Subscribe now

The Small Vanishings

What makes this hard to catch is that the disappearance is rarely dramatic. You are standing at the sink, doing the most unimpressive task in human history, and then suddenly you are no longer there. The hand is still moving. The toothbrush is still doing its little prison scrub. But inwardly you are in a courtroom, or an old conversation, or a fantasy where everyone finally understands your brilliance and regrets their previous stupidity. Attention has been hijacked, and because this happens all day long, the mind treats it as normal.

That is part of the problem. We think wandering is harmless because it is common. We think because everyone lives like a haunted Roomba, bumping from task to task while mentally elsewhere, that this must simply be what a human mind does. But the deeper traditions have always said no. This is not freedom. This is sleep with errands.

How Attention Gets Stolen

Helminski’s point is not merely that attention wanders. It is that attention gets captured by what attracts or repels us, and the ego then mistakes this reactivity for choice. That means the issue is not just distraction in the generic sense. The issue is that our attention is usually moved by appetite, irritation, fantasy, fear, vanity, and unfinished inner theater. Something in us is always ready to lunge.

You see this in embarrassingly ordinary places. You are running errands and somebody cuts you off in the parking lot. Now the body is in one place, but inwardly you are writing a thesis on the collapse of civilization. Or you are folding laundry and suddenly remembering an insult from three years ago with the emotional freshness of a live broadcast. Or you are brushing your teeth and by the fourth tooth you are no longer in the bathroom at all. You are in some imaginary future where you have finally explained yourself correctly.

The mind is a talented escape artist. Give it a sink and it will build a portal.

The Witness Does Not Scream

The good news is that the inner witness does not need to arrive as some heroic spiritual personality. It does not need robes. It does not need incense. It does not need a soundtrack that sounds like monks mating with synthesizers. It begins much more quietly than that.

It begins the moment you notice.

That is all.

Not fixing. Not scolding. Not launching a self-improvement campaign because you have once again failed to remain luminously present while buying toothpaste. Just noticing. “Ah. I’m gone.” That moment matters because the instant you see the wandering, you are no longer completely fused with it. Something in you has stepped half an inch back. That half inch is sacred territory.

Why Gentleness Matters

Most people ruin the practice right there by turning the witness into a hall monitor. They notice they are gone and immediately begin the familiar inner sermon. “Why am I like this? Why can’t I stay present? I should be better at this by now.” Which is just another form of leaving. Now you are no longer lost in fantasy or irritation. You are lost in self-judgment. Same building. Different room.

The witness is not a critic. It is a simple, steady seeing. It does not panic when attention slips. It does not make your wandering into evidence for the prosecution. It just notices, and then invites a return. Very gently. The whole movement is closer to turning your face back toward the moment than it is to beating yourself into compliance.

That matters because harshness is still ego. It still believes force is the answer. Presence usually grows better in honesty than in violence.

Ordinary Life Is the Training Ground

This is why the real practice does not happen only in formally spiritual moments. It happens while brushing your teeth, yes, but also while walking into the post office, waiting at a red light, listening to somebody tell a long story when your personality would strongly prefer to flee the country, and standing in line while every cell in your body demands stimulation.

These ordinary moments are not a distraction from the work. They are the work.

The kitchen is where you find out whether attention can stay put without being bribed. The grocery store is where you discover whether your peace depends on no one being annoying. The commute is where you learn whether your interior life belongs to presence or to grievance. The little vanishings of the day are not proof that you are failing. They are where the mechanism becomes visible.

And once it becomes visible, it can no longer run the whole monastery unchecked.

Catching Yourself in the Act

What starts to change over time is not that you never disappear. It is that you begin to catch the movement sooner. At first, you notice three minutes later that you have been lost in some fantasy argument while loading the dishwasher. Then maybe thirty seconds later. Then in the middle of the spiral itself. Then, once in a while, right at the moment attention starts to slip toward the back door.

That is not a small thing. That is the strengthening of inner life.

Because the point is not to create some rigid state where you never drift, never react, never lose the thread. The point is to build familiarity with the one in you that can notice without collapsing. The one that can return. The one that can remain a little more stable while the rest of you performs its usual vaudeville.

Coming Back Without Romance

There is nothing glamorous about this. Nobody gets to post a mystical selfie because they returned to the present while standing in line at Walgreens. This is deeply unsexy work. Which is probably one reason it is real.

But over time, this simple practice of noticing and returning begins to do something substantial. It weakens the automatic trance. It gives the witness more substance. It teaches attention that it does not have to obey every impulse, every irritation, every fantasy with a megaphone. It lets you inhabit the ordinary without constantly fleeing it.

And then once in a while, in the middle of something completely unimpressive, you are just there. Really there. Not performing presence. Not narrating it. Not being pleased with yourself for having achieved it.

Just there.

Which turns out to be a far greater miracle than most of us were trained to look for.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

You Don’t Have to Like It to Pay Attention

Virgin Monk Boy — Sun, 05 Apr 2026 13:03:19 GMT

This reflection grows out of the same stream as Surrender and Attention: The Cosmic Breath: Cynthia Bourgeault’s work with Practicing Living Presence, read through Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence and that whole Sufi insistence that the problem is not simply what we feel, but what keeps organizing our attention beneath the feeling. One of the things that starts to become obvious, slowly and then all at once, is that most of us do not actually place attention. We follow preference. We move toward what pleases us, brace against what irritates us, and call that being a person. But preference is a terrible spiritual director. It keeps the soul shallow while convincing us we are being honest.

Subscribe now

Where Preference Hides

Preference rarely shows up looking dramatic. It usually appears in much softer clothing. It sounds like discernment. It sounds like taste. It sounds like, “This just doesn’t resonate,” or “I’m not in the right space for this today.” Sometimes that is true. A lot of the time it is just the ego refusing to stay anywhere that does not immediately reward it. The problem is not that we have likes and dislikes. The problem is that we have made them the gatekeepers of attention. Nothing gets our full presence unless the personality approves.

The Attention That Gets Captured

Once you begin to watch this in real time, the mechanism is almost embarrassingly easy to see. Attention moves along until it hits something attractive or irritating, and then it sticks. It is pulled by praise, snagged by insult, seduced by stimulation, repelled by discomfort. The ego calls this freedom because it got to react first. But reaction is not freedom. Reaction is just bondage with better branding. If your attention can only stay where it feels rewarded, then your inner life is still being governed by appetite.

What We Mistake for Authenticity

Modern spirituality has made this worse by teaching people to trust every internal weather pattern as if it were revelation. If you feel open, it must be aligned. If you feel resistance, it must be wrong. If you feel bored, surely the soul is not meant for this. But boredom is often just wounded preference with nothing to feed on. Resistance is often vanity being denied its usual snacks. And alignment, at least in the deeper sense, does not always feel pleasant. Sometimes it feels like staying in the room when nothing in you is getting applause.

The Practice of Showing Up Anyway

This is where attention stops being a mood and becomes a practice. Not a clenched practice. Not a performative one. Just the simple act of remaining. You do not have to pretend to like the moment. You do not have to decorate it with spiritual language. You do not have to say the traffic jam is a blessing or the tedious conversation is secretly your guru. You only have to stop outsourcing your presence to preference. You stay. You notice. You let attention rest where it is instead of constantly asking whether the personality is having a good time.

What Changes When You Stay

At first, this feels almost disappointing. There is no instant glow. No soundtrack. No angelic fog machine. What appears instead is much quieter. The moment becomes more textured. The thing you wanted to escape begins to reveal details. A task that felt dead has its own rhythm. A person you were resisting becomes less flat. Even your own irritation becomes more interesting when you stop feeding it and start watching it. Preference had been reducing the world to a yes-or-no button. Attention, when it is freed from that reflex, starts giving reality back its depth.

Beyond Like and Dislike

This is also where a different kind of aliveness begins to show up. Not happiness exactly. Not pleasure. Something steadier than that. A vitality that comes from contact rather than approval. You begin to sense that being fully here has its own nourishment. The moment does not need to be improved before it can be inhabited. And this is where a lot of spiritual vanity dies, because the self that wanted to curate every experience starts to realize it is not actually the center of the room.

The Soul Gets Built Here

If attention only goes where the ego is pleased, then the soul never develops much strength. It remains dependent, reactive, and easily bought. But every time you stay present without demanding immediate emotional payment, something in you gets less flimsy. The inner witness grows. The tyranny of preference weakens. You stop being dragged so easily by attraction and aversion. This is not glamorous work, which is probably why it is real. A soul is not built through constant self-confirmation. It is built through contact, honesty, and the slow liberation of attention from the need to be flattered.

What This Looks Like in Ordinary Life

It usually starts in embarrassingly unromantic places. Brushing your teeth without wandering off into fantasy by the fourth tooth. Listening to someone without spending the whole time building your rebuttal. Folding laundry without needing a podcast, a mood, a sign from God, and a small miracle to get through it. Paying attention while annoyed. Paying attention while bored. Paying attention while unseen. This is where preference starts to lose its throne. Not in the Himalayas. Not in a branded retreat center. In the kitchen. In the car. In the line you did not want to stand in.

The Freedom on the Other Side

What begins to emerge from this is not passivity. It is not numbness. It is not becoming the kind of person who smiles beatifically while spiritually bypassing the whole human condition. It is something far more useful. You become less coerced. Less hijackable. Less easy to manipulate through praise, outrage, novelty, or discomfort. And because of that, attention becomes available for something deeper than reaction. It can begin to serve presence itself.

Returning Without Romance

Eventually it becomes obvious that the issue was never whether you liked the moment. The issue was whether you could stay conscious inside it. Preference had made attention conditional. It turned presence into a customer loyalty program. But the deeper work keeps cutting through that arrangement. You do not have to like it to pay attention. You do not have to enjoy it to be changed by it. You do not have to feel spiritually special for the moment to become real.

And that is where the whole thing starts to open.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Surrender and Attention: The Cosmic Breath

Virgin Monk Boy — Tue, 24 Mar 2026 20:05:54 GMT

A Rhythm Hidden in Plain Sight

This reflection grows out of continued work with Cynthia Bourgeault’s Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, which itself draws deeply from Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence and the Sufi understanding of the inner life as a movement of energy rather than a set of isolated techniques. One of the things that begins to surface, not all at once but gradually, is that attention and surrender are not really two separate practices that need to be balanced like competing priorities. They behave more like a single movement that we tend to split apart. When that movement is working, there is a kind of coherence that is hard to describe but easy to recognize. When it isn’t, the problem usually doesn’t show up as failure. It shows up as something slightly off that you can feel but don’t immediately question.

Subscribe now

Where Attention Begins

Most people come into this work through attention because it is easier to recognize. You can see where your mind goes. You can watch how quickly it gets pulled into something and how long it stays there without you noticing. And at some point you realize that returning attention changes the situation in a way that feels almost disproportionate to how simple the action is. A thought loses some of its grip. An emotion doesn’t build in quite the same way. It becomes obvious that attention is not just observing experience, it is participating in it, whether you intend it to or not.

But even here, something subtle begins to happen if you stay with it long enough. The return of attention can start to feel like something you are responsible for maintaining. It is no longer just noticing and coming back. There is a slight pressure to keep it there, to not lose it again, and that pressure doesn’t always announce itself as tension. It can feel like you are doing the practice correctly. It can even feel like progress.

When Attention Becomes Effort

If you watch that closely, the quality of attention changes. It starts to feel held. The mind begins to keep track of itself, almost like it is checking whether it is still present. And the strange part is that nothing looks obviously wrong from the outside. You are still aware. You are still returning. But the whole thing carries a different tone. There is a kind of effort running underneath it that wasn’t there at the beginning, and over time that effort starts to accumulate.

This is usually where people double down without realizing it. They try to stabilize attention more firmly, thinking that the instability is the problem. But the instability is not the problem. The tightening is. Attention, when it is working the way it naturally does, doesn’t need to be forced into place. When it starts to feel like something you have to hold together, it has already shifted into something else.

The Releasing Movement of Surrender

This is where surrender enters, although it usually doesn’t enter in a way that feels dramatic. It shows up more as a small release than as a big shift. Where attention gathers, surrender lets go of the grip that forms around what has been gathered. It doesn’t remove awareness. It removes the need to control what awareness is resting on. That distinction is easy to miss, because from the outside both can look like “being present.”

In the Sufi language, this is described as a shift in where the center of the self is operating from. Not in a conceptual way, but in a very practical one. Experience is still happening, but it is not being organized as quickly around preference, resistance, or identity. There is a little more space between what is happening and how it is being taken personally.

When Surrender Loses Its Center

But surrender, taken on its own, doesn’t solve the problem either. It creates a different one. Without attention, surrender becomes difficult to distinguish from drifting. Things are allowed, but they are not actually being seen. The mind moves, and instead of noticing that movement, it gets carried by it. It feels softer than effort, which is why it can be convincing, but something is missing. There is no real center holding the experience together.

You can usually feel this as a kind of vagueness. Nothing is particularly wrong, but nothing is particularly clear either. And because there is no obvious tension, it can take longer to recognize that awareness has thinned out rather than deepened.

The Breath as a Map of the Inner Life

The metaphor that shows up repeatedly in this teaching is breath, and it is not just poetic. Attention behaves like an inhale. It draws awareness inward and gathers what has been scattered. Surrender behaves like an exhale. It releases the contraction that naturally forms when something is gathered. If you exaggerate either side, the system starts to feel off almost immediately. Too much inhale, and everything tightens. Too much exhale, and everything loses structure.

What is interesting is that no one needs to be taught how to breathe in the first place. The problem is not the absence of the rhythm. It is the interference with it. We emphasize one side, then try to correct by emphasizing the other, and miss the fact that the movement only works as a whole.

The Felt Sense of Imbalance

Once you start paying attention to this, the imbalance becomes easier to notice. When attention is overemphasized, there is a kind of subtle strain behind awareness. It feels like something is being maintained. When surrender is overemphasized, there is a different feeling. Awareness is there, but it is not anchored. It moves too easily, and because of that, it doesn’t deepen.

Neither state looks dramatic, which is why they are easy to stay in. But over time, both create a kind of fatigue. One from holding too much. The other from not holding anything at all.

When the Two Movements Meet

When attention and surrender begin to function together, the change is not dramatic, but it is noticeable. Awareness is present, but it is not being held in place. Experience is allowed, but it is not pulling attention away with it. There is a sense of participation that doesn’t rely on effort and doesn’t collapse into passivity. It feels more like something settling into alignment than something being achieved.

And this is usually where people try to grab it, which immediately disrupts it again.

Working With the Rhythm Directly

The practical side of this is almost too simple, which is part of why it gets complicated. You notice where attention has gone, and you allow it to return. But in that return, you also allow something to release. You don’t try to secure the moment. You don’t try to make it stable. You let it be what it is, even if what it is isn’t particularly calm or clear.

Then attention moves again, and you notice that too. Over time, it becomes more obvious that attention doesn’t really behave like a steady beam. It comes and goes in smaller movements, and the more you stop trying to force it into continuity, the more naturally it stabilizes on its own.

Beyond Reaction and Passivity

At a certain point, this also changes how you understand what is usually called attention and surrender. What we normally call attention is often just reactivity being held in place. What we call surrender is often just disengagement. When both begin to align with something deeper, they don’t feel like opposites anymore. They feel like different aspects of the same intelligence working through awareness.

The Quiet Reorganization

The effects of this are gradual. There isn’t a dramatic shift so much as a reorganization that becomes noticeable over time. Attention is less scattered, not because you are forcing it to stay, but because it is not being pulled as easily. Reactions still happen, but they don’t build as quickly. There is more space in the experience, and that space changes how everything else behaves.

Returning to the Breath

Eventually, it becomes clear that this rhythm was never something that needed to be constructed. It was already functioning. The problem was the way it was being interrupted. And the work, if it can be called that, is less about doing something new and more about noticing where that interruption happens and letting it settle.

And when it does, even briefly, there is a sense that awareness is no longer trying to manage itself. It is simply here, moving the way it already knows how to move.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

The Energy of Attention

Virgin Monk Boy — Tue, 10 Mar 2026 17:10:42 GMT

This reflection grows out of my continued work with Cynthia Bourgeault’s Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within. Bourgeault’s teaching in that course is itself a sustained engagement with Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence, which explores the inner mechanics of attention within the Sufi contemplative tradition. One of the insights that gradually surfaces in that stream of teaching is disarmingly simple: attention is not just a mental function. It is an energetic act. Where we place it quietly shapes the quality of our awareness and, over time, the formation of the soul itself.

Noticing Where the Mind Actually Goes

Most people imagine attention as something passive. Life happens, thoughts appear, emotions flare up, and the mind simply reacts. Attention follows whatever happens to be loudest in the moment.

But if you begin watching the movement of attention carefully, the situation looks different.

Subscribe now

Attention is not merely following experience. It is feeding it.

Where attention settles, something begins to grow. The thought becomes more vivid. The emotion gains strength. The story we are telling ourselves acquires weight and gravity. A passing irritation can turn into a long internal argument. A small worry can become a loop the mind returns to again and again.

It is tempting to assume the thought itself is the cause of the emotional state. But often the real cause is simpler: attention kept returning to it.

What attention repeatedly touches begins to take root.

The Economy of Distraction

In earlier centuries spiritual teachers warned about “the wandering mind.” Today wandering attention has become an entire economic model.

Phones vibrate. Notifications appear. Headlines compete with videos, comments compete with headlines, and algorithms quietly refine their ability to keep the mind moving from one stimulus to the next. None of these moments feel dramatic on their own, yet the cumulative effect is surprisingly powerful.

Attention becomes scattered.

By the end of the day the mind may feel overstimulated while the inner life feels oddly thin. Many people experience this as fatigue without quite understanding the cause.

It is not always that we have done too much.

Often it is that our attention has been pulled in too many directions.

Energy follows attention. When attention fragments, the energy of awareness fragments with it.

A Small Experiment

The effect becomes obvious once you try a simple experiment.

Spend twenty minutes scrolling through arguments online. Watch the mind react to opinions, headlines, sarcasm, outrage. Notice what happens inside the body while this is happening.

Then stop.

Put the device down and sit quietly for a few minutes. Let attention rest on the movement of the breath. Nothing complicated. Just the simple rhythm of breathing in and breathing out.

Most people notice the shift almost immediately.

The nervous system begins to soften. Thoughts slow down. A quiet sense of steadiness returns that was not present a few minutes earlier.

Nothing in the external world changed.

Only the direction of attention.

That small shift reveals something important about the mechanics of consciousness. Attention is not neutral. It directs the flow of energy within the psyche.

Where attention rests, vitality gathers.

The Seeds That Receive Water

A helpful way to understand attention is to think of the inner life as a garden.

Within every human being there are many seeds: fear, curiosity, anger, patience, compassion, resentment, generosity. All of them exist in potential. But not all of them grow equally.

The seeds that receive water and sunlight are the ones that flourish.

Attention functions very much like water in this metaphor. Whatever repeatedly receives our attention becomes stronger within the landscape of the personality. If attention continually circles around grievance, grievance becomes familiar territory. If attention repeatedly feeds anxiety, the nervous system begins expecting anxiety as its default condition.

But attention can nourish other qualities as well.

It can strengthen patience. It can deepen perception. It can quietly cultivate compassion by allowing the heart to remain present long enough to actually feel another person’s reality.

The garden grows according to what receives water.

The Practice of Recollection

For centuries contemplative traditions have understood this dynamic. In Christian mystical teaching the process of gathering scattered attention is often called recollection. The word itself carries a gentle wisdom: to recollect is simply to collect again what has been dispersed.

Recollection does not require withdrawing from the world. It does not demand heroic spiritual effort. It is simply the repeated act of bringing attention back to the immediacy of the present moment.

At first the effect appears small.

The breath becomes more noticeable. The body releases a little tension. Thoughts continue to move through the mind, but they lose some of their urgency. Instead of pulling awareness in every direction, they begin appearing more like passing weather.

The mind is still active.

But it no longer occupies the entire sky.

The Gathering of Energy

Something interesting begins happening when attention stabilizes even slightly.

Energy gathers.

Awareness begins feeling more coherent. Emotional reactions soften because they are no longer instantly fueled by attention. The mind becomes capable of observing its own activity without being completely swept away by it.

This does not require mystical fireworks. It is a subtle shift in the way awareness functions.

Instead of constantly scattering outward, attention begins resting more deeply in the present moment. When that happens, another quality of consciousness becomes noticeable beneath the surface movement of thoughts.

Many contemplative traditions describe this as presence.

It is quiet. It is steady. And it was there the entire time, waiting for attention to stop running in every direction.

Becoming What We Attend To

Over long periods of time attention shapes character in ways that are rarely obvious at first. Human beings gradually become what they habitually attend to.

If attention continually feeds distraction, agitation becomes the atmosphere of the mind. If attention remains trapped in resentment or worry, those emotional states slowly organize the psyche around themselves.

But when attention repeatedly returns to presence, something different begins unfolding.

The inner life gains stability. Insight appears more easily. Emotional storms pass more quickly because they are no longer receiving constant reinforcement.

Little by little the center of gravity within awareness shifts.

And it all begins with something very small: noticing where attention has gone.

The Shape of the Soul

The practice itself is almost embarrassingly simple.

Notice where attention is resting.

When it has wandered into agitation or endless mental commentary, gently return it to the living moment in front of you. Not with force, not with frustration, but with the quiet patience of someone tending a garden.

Each return gathers a little energy.

Each moment of recollection strengthens the capacity for presence.

Over time the inner life becomes less scattered and more whole.

And slowly, almost invisibly, the soul begins taking the shape of what it continually beholds.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

The Double Awareness Practice

Virgin Monk Boy — Sat, 21 Feb 2026 19:54:42 GMT

This post grows out of the same stream as Voluntary Attention vs. Daydreaming. It’s shaped by the “double attention” teaching that shows up again and again in Cynthia Bourgeault’s Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, which itself is a sustained engagement with Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence. What follows is not a call to withdraw from the world, nor a pitch for spiritual numbness dressed up as wisdom. It emerges from a simpler observation: most of our suffering is not caused by experience itself, but by how completely we disappear into it. Double awareness is the practice of staying in contact with the watcher while still meeting the moment as it is.

Subscribe now

The Single Awareness Trap

Most people live inside a one-channel system. Attention goes to an object, a thought, a person, a task, a worry, a sensation, and that is where the “I” goes too. We call it normal. We call it focus. We call it being engaged. But a lot of what we call engagement is actually absorption, and absorption comes with a price. When you collapse entirely into what you’re noticing, you lose contact with the field of awareness that holds the noticing.

In practice, this is why a small irritation can become a full mood. It is why a single comment can hijack an entire day. It is why scrolling can feel like ten minutes but steal an hour. The object pulls, attention follows, identity follows, and the watcher goes offline. You are still conscious, but you are not present.

Helminski names this clearly in the language of energy. There is a level of attention where you can be intensely active while still losing yourself in what you are doing. It can look productive. It can even look creative. But it is missing the quiet center that knows it is happening.

What Double Awareness Actually Means

Double awareness is the ability to hold two realities at the same time: the content of experience and the awareness of experiencing. It is the capacity to remain aware of both the ship and the river. The ship is the thought, the feeling, the conversation, the task, the noise of your inner life. The river is the larger field of being in which all of it is occurring.

This matters because the watcher is not a concept. It is a location. When you are in it, your life has space. When you are not, your life becomes a tunnel.

Double awareness is not detachment in the sense most people mean it. It is not stepping away from feeling. It is not “rising above” your humanity. It is not dissociating into some cold spiritual perch. It is closer to widening the frame. You can still feel anger, but anger is no longer the whole room. You can still feel desire, but desire is no longer driving the car. The watcher does not cancel experience. It contextualizes it.

The Watcher Is Not the Ego

One reason this practice matters is that the ego does not like being observed. The ego likes being right, being safe, being justified, being admired, being defended. It does not like being seen as a pattern. It does not like being caught in the act. That is why the simple shift into witnessing can feel like a small rebellion. Something in you steps back and the whole system becomes less compulsive.

This is also why double awareness is different from self-monitoring. Self-monitoring is the ego watching itself and trying to manage the image. Double awareness is awareness itself becoming conscious of itself. One is performance. The other is presence.

If you want a simple diagnostic, notice how it feels. Ego-monitoring feels tight. It has a judgmental tone. It has an agenda. It is always trying to improve something. Witnessing feels spacious. It does not need to fix the moment in order to see it. It has clarity without panic.

The Core Mechanic

In the most practical terms, the practice is this: reserve a portion of attention for being itself. Helminski calls the path “fastidious remembrance.”

The word fastidious is perfect here because it implies care, precision,

is not a one-time awakening. It is a reawakening, again and again, inside ordinary life.

You do not need to hold the watcher continuously. In fact, trying to do that usually turns the practice into strain. The way this develops is more like a pulse. Awareness opens for a moment. You recognize. Then you get pulled back into the ship. Then you remember again. Over time, the pulses become more frequent, and the watcher begins to feel less like a special state and more like a stable ground.

The goal is not to never get lost. The goal is to shorten the time you stay lost before you recognize what happened.

Three Practices to Build Double Awareness

The first practice is the simplest: name the movement of attention. Not out loud necessarily, but inwardly. “Attention just bent.” “I got pulled.” “I’m contracting.” “I’m chasing.” This is not analysis. It is recognition. The recognition itself is the watcher waking up. You cannot do this from inside absorption. The moment you notice the movement, you are already partially free of it.

The second practice is to anchor awareness in the body while staying engaged with the moment. Pick one subtle point as a home base. The contact of your feet with the ground. The sensation of breathing in the chest. The feeling of your hands. Do not force it. Let it be light. You are not trying to meditate your way out of the conversation. You are simply giving attention a second anchor so it stops being dragged around by whatever is loudest.

The third practice is to train double awareness in low-stakes moments so it shows up when the stakes are high. Practice it when you are making coffee. Practice it while reading a text message. Practice it while brushing your teeth. Practice it when you are mildly bored. Practice it when you are mildly pleased. If you only try to practice when you are triggered, you will treat it like an emergency tool instead of a way of living.

Living With Both Hands on the Wheel

Double awareness is not a spiritual accessory. It is how you stop being played by your own inner weather. Without it, the day belongs to whatever captures you first. With it, life begins to reorganize around a deeper center.

You still act. You still speak. You still make decisions. But you are less likely to be driven by unseen forces. A small gap opens between stimulus and reaction, and that gap is not emptiness. It is intelligence. It is choice. It is being.

The world does not need you to withdraw. It needs you to show up without vanishing into the noise. It needs people who can stay aware of the ship without forgetting the river.

That is the whole practice.

And it begins with one quiet move: noticing that you are noticing.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Voluntary Attention vs. Daydreaming

Virgin Monk Boy — Mon, 16 Feb 2026 14:40:23 GMT

This essay continues the series reflecting on Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, particularly the movement in Chapter 6 toward what Helminski calls “reserving some attention for being itself.” In the previous piece, we explored the claim that the ego has no attention of its own — that it lives parasitically on whatever awareness we fail to anchor in being. Here we take that insight further. If attention is the currency of consciousness, then how we use it determines whether we live from vitality or from psychic exhaustion. And nowhere is this more subtle than in the difference between unconscious daydreaming and voluntary attention.

Subscribe now

When Imagination Becomes Identification

At first glance, daydreaming appears innocent. It feels like creativity, like interior space, like harmless mental wandering. We drift into imagined conversations, replay old arguments, rehearse future successes, refine scenes that never quite unfolded the way we wished they had. The mind moves, constructs, embellishes. Yet something decisive is usually missing: awareness that we are doing it. The subject disappears into the story. We are no longer imagining; we are inhabiting. The narrative absorbs us, and attention becomes entangled in the very images it produces.

Helminski describes a lower level of energy in which we lose ourselves in what we are doing. There is energy present, even intensity, but no retained center of consciousness. Daydreaming functions in precisely this way. The mind is active, but the thread of being is absent. We are carried by associative chains, emotional residues, and subtle desires that animate the scene. It is not the imagination itself that drains us; it is identification with what the imagination produces.

The Desire Structure Beneath Fantasy

Most daydreaming is fueled by desire. Not crude desire necessarily, but refined forms of it: the longing to be seen, to be vindicated, to be secure, to be finally complete. Helminski reminds us that desire is bottomless; objects change, but the craving structure remains. When attention binds itself to imagined objects that promise completion, it reinforces the assumption that being as it is now is insufficient. Fulfillment is projected outward — or forward — into a mental construct. In that projection, presence thins. Energy contracts around the fantasy. Afterwards, we often feel subtly depleted, though we cannot say why.

Reserving Attention for Being

Voluntary attention moves differently. It does not eliminate imagination. It alters the location of the center. Helminski speaks of the “straight and narrow path” as fastidious remembrance of being. To reserve attention for being is not to suppress thought but to remain aware of the field in which thought appears. You can imagine and know that you are imagining. You can rehearse and remain present. The subject does not collapse into the object. There is a retained, quiet sense of “I am here.”

This difference is almost imperceptible at first, yet energetically it is decisive. When attention remains anchored in being, imagination unfolds within a larger field of awareness. It becomes transparent rather than possessive. The story no longer defines the self. It is simply a movement within consciousness. Helminski’s description of sliding the sense of identity along a scale helps illuminate this shift. At one end, identity is fixed in roles and emotional definitions: “I am the rejected one,” “I am the future success,” “I am the wounded child.” At the deepest end, identity rests in simple presence: “I am.” Daydreaming that drains us usually occurs at the first two levels. Voluntary attention returns us to the third.

The Pulse of Conscious Awareness

There is also a temporal dimension to this work. Conscious awareness does not sustain itself by force. It pulses. We drift. We become absorbed. We lose the thread. The practice is not to maintain an artificial vigilance but to recognize, even briefly, when we have been carried away. The instant of seeing is already a return. Nothing dramatic needs to happen. The fantasy need not be condemned. The moment awareness reappears, energy re-centers. Psychic drain stops because identification loosens.

This is why the distinction between mindfulness and seeing matters. Mindfulness often implies a sustained slowing down, a deliberate attentiveness unfolding in time. Seeing, by contrast, is instantaneous. It cuts through. In a flash, you realize, “I am lost in this.” That realization is not self-reproach; it is being reasserting itself. Even if the imagination continues, it now unfolds within a conscious field rather than as an unconscious current.

The Real Inner War

The inner war, then, is not between imagination and rational control. It is between unconscious identification and conscious presence. One tightens around narratives that promise completion. The other rests in being and allows imagination to arise without captivity. One consumes attention. The other liberates it.

When attention is anchored in being, imagination becomes creative participation rather than compensatory escape. It does not attempt to fix identity or secure worth. It expresses. It plays. It serves. And paradoxically, vitality increases rather than diminishes. We are no longer borrowing energy from presence to fuel fantasy. We are allowing presence itself to animate imagination.

In this sense, the practice is simple but not easy: reserve some attention for being. Notice when you disappear into the story. Notice the contraction. Notice the return. Each moment of seeing strengthens the center. Each release of identification restores energy.

Attention is not a small faculty. It is the conduit through which being becomes conscious of itself. Whether we scatter it in unconscious narratives or anchor it in living presence determines the quality of our life. Daydreaming that feeds identification drains us because it forgets the source. Voluntary attention renews us because it remembers.

And perhaps this is the quiet invitation beneath the whole teaching: not to wage war against imagination, not to tighten into spiritual self-monitoring, but to become intimate with the movement of attention itself. To notice when it contracts. To notice when it opens. To notice when you vanish into narrative and when you remain rooted in being. Over time, this noticing reshapes the inner architecture. The compulsion to escape weakens. The need to complete yourself through story softens. What remains is simpler and more stable than fantasy ever was — a steady participation in being that does not depend on rehearsal, revision, or imagined arrival. From there, even imagination becomes transparent to its source.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

The Ego Has No Attention of Its Own

Virgin Monk Boy — Thu, 12 Feb 2026 15:28:17 GMT

This post grows out of work I’ve been doing with Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, which itself is a sustained engagement with Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence. In particular, it draws from the chapter titled The Power of Being. What follows is not an argument against the ego, nor a call to suppress desire or preference. It emerges instead from a quieter observation: the ego does not possess attention. It feeds on it. It redirects it. But it does not generate it.

We tend to assume that attention belongs to the self we habitually experience. We say, “I decided to focus,” or “I chose to think about that.” Yet when we begin to look more closely, the sequence is different. Something catches us first. A memory, a notification, a tone of voice, a sensation in the body. Attention moves. Only afterward does the ego step in and narrate what is happening. It claims authorship over a movement that had already begun.

Projection and the Story-Maker

Helminski makes the radical claim that what we project outward onto things is already within us. We imagine that the object, the person, the circumstance is responsible for the state we are experiencing. In reality, attention has already been drawn by attraction or aversion. The ego then fastens onto that movement and builds a story around it. “I like this.” “I can’t stand that.” “This will complete me.” “That threatens me.” Attention, which arises from a deeper source, becomes captured inside the commentary.

Subscribe now

The Ego’s Steering Mechanism

The ego does not create attention; it directs it through preference. It moves attention toward what promises reinforcement of identity and away from what threatens it. The direction matters.

When praise appears, attention leans forward. It wants to extend the experience, secure it, deepen it. When criticism appears, attention contracts. It scans for defense, explanation, counterattack. Attraction expands; aversion tightens. Both are movements within attention, but they are not the same movement.

The ego lives inside that oscillation. It does not know how to rest in simple awareness. It requires contrast. It requires something to pursue or something to resist. Without attraction or aversion, it feels as though nothing is happening. And so it keeps scanning, bending attention toward the next object that confirms or protects its sense of self.

The Field of Being

This is where Bourgeault’s distinction becomes critical. She speaks of the difference between being lost in activity and retaining a subtle awareness of the field in which the activity unfolds. That field is not reactive. It does not lunge or recoil. It simply knows. When even a sliver of attention remains in that field, something shifts. The ego is no longer the sole interpreter of experience.

We do not reclaim attention by fighting our preferences. Trying to eliminate likes and dislikes only creates another layer of reactivity. Instead, we begin by noticing the moment attention has been bent. “Ah. There it goes.” That recognition does not come from the ego. The ego does not enjoy being observed. The recognition arises from Being itself.

Space Within Reaction

In that instant of seeing, the movement does not necessarily stop. You may still feel anger. You may still want what you want. You may still act. But the action is no longer entirely driven by unconscious pull. A measure of space enters. The field widens. The reaction becomes one element within awareness rather than the center of it.

Helminski describes the spiritual path as one of “fastidious remembrance”. This remembrance is not about holding a state. It is about repeatedly rediscovering that attention originates in Being, not in the ego’s commentary. The ego cannot create the light of awareness any more than a lens can produce light. It can only color what shines through it.

The Deeper Source

The ego will continue to prefer. That is its nature. But it no longer steers alone. Attention, reclaimed even briefly, begins to source from a deeper center. And from that center, action is less reactive, less compulsive, less driven by the endless oscillation between reinforcement and threat.

We do not transcend the ego by defeating it. We outgrow its dominance by remembering where attention truly comes from. Being is already present. Attention is already luminous. The work is not to manufacture awareness, but to stop mistaking the ego’s movements for its source.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Fastidious Remembrance: The Practice of Catching Yourself in the Act of Being

Virgin Monk Boy — Tue, 27 Jan 2026 15:11:30 GMT

We tend to treat Being as something we must enter, generate, or maintain. We approach it like a discipline to master or a state to stabilize. In doing so, we quietly miss the more radical truth. Being does not arrive as a possession. It reveals itself as a recognition. Brief. Fleeting. Undramatic. And easily overlooked.

Subscribe now

Helminski names the work fastidious remembrance of being. The phrase is precise. Fastidious does not mean tense or obsessive. It means attentive. Careful. Willing to notice the smallest shift in inner posture. Remembrance does not mean recall of something absent. It means recognition of something already present.

The practice, if it can be called that, is not about sustaining awareness. It is about catching yourself in the act of already being aware.

Being Is Not a State. It Is a Pulse.

One of the most helpful correctives in this chapter is the insistence that consciousness is not a steady condition. It is a pulse.

There is a common fantasy among spiritual practitioners that one day awareness will “turn on” and remain on. That presence will become continuous, seamless, and uninterrupted. But this expectation belongs more to perfectionism than to wisdom.

Consciousness flashes. It opens. It closes. It returns. It disappears again.

You notice yourself noticing. Then you are gone.

You notice again. Then you are gone again.

The mistake is not losing the awareness. The mistake is believing you were supposed to keep it.

Fastidious remembrance works with the pulse rather than against it. The moment you see, the work has already been done. No need to prolong it. No need to stabilize it. No need to congratulate yourself. The pulse will return on its own time.

This is why the practice belongs in ordinary life rather than in protected spiritual conditions. Silence can help you recognize the pulse, but friction reveals it.

Why Ordinary States Are the Best Teachers

Being announces itself most clearly through contrast. It is easier to recognize awareness when something in us is off-balance than when everything is smooth.

Boredom is one such doorway. Boredom has a distinctive texture. A flattening. A mild irritation with time itself. The invitation is not to escape boredom, but to notice it. The instant you see boredom as an object rather than an identity, awareness has already appeared.

Hurry is another doorway. Hurry compresses attention. It pulls the mind forward and creates a subtle sense of emergency. Catching yourself in hurry does not require slowing down. It requires seeing. The seeing itself is not hurried, even if the body continues to move quickly.

Annoyance is especially useful. Annoyance is sticky. It wants to justify itself. The moment you catch the storyline forming, the moment you notice the tightening behind the eyes or in the chest, awareness has entered the room. Nothing needs to be resolved. Seeing is enough.

Pleasure belongs here too. Many people only attempt presence when they are distressed, turning awareness into a coping mechanism. But pleasure offers the same opening. The moment you know you are enjoying something, the pulse is present. Being does not oppose enjoyment. It contextualizes it.

Practicing only in suffering turns presence into a tool. Practicing across all states allows it to remain what it is.

The Difference Between Seeing and Fixing

A crucial distinction in this work is the difference between seeing and correcting.

Western spiritual culture is deeply infected with the assumption that awareness exists in order to improve behavior. We notice in order to intervene. We observe in order to optimize. Even mindfulness is often recruited into self-management.

But Helminski’s instruction is subtler. Awareness does not need to fix what it sees. In fact, the impulse to fix is often what obscures the pulse.

Seeing is instantaneous. It happens outside of time. The moment you see clearly, something shifts, whether or not circumstances change. Fixing happens in time. It requires effort, strategy, and outcome.

Fastidious remembrance trains the eye, not the will.

You may remain annoyed after you notice annoyance. You may continue rushing after you notice hurry. You may still feel bored after you notice boredom. The difference is that you are no longer identical with the state. Something else is present, quietly containing it.

This is not detachment. It is intimacy without fusion.

Reserving Attention for Being

Helminski speaks of “reserving some attention for being itself.” This does not mean splitting your focus or constantly monitoring yourself. It means allowing a small margin of awareness to remain unclaimed by the activity at hand.

You are fully engaged in what you are doing, but not completely lost in it.

This is the difference between being absorbed and being aware. Absorption collapses the subject into the object. Awareness preserves relationship.

The image often used is that of the diver sitting on a rock at the bottom of a river, watching the current pass overhead. Thoughts, emotions, sensations, and impulses flow by, but awareness remains anchored elsewhere.

This does not require effort. It requires permission.

Most of us abandon awareness the moment life becomes compelling. Fastidious remembrance is the decision not to abandon it entirely.

Why the Practice Feels So Small

One of the reasons this practice is underestimated is that it does not produce fireworks. There is no dramatic shift of consciousness. No guarantee of peace. No reliable emotional payoff.

Often the pulse lasts only an instant. A flicker. A quiet recognition. And then it is gone.

This can feel disappointing until something deeper is understood. The transformation does not occur in the duration of awareness. It occurs in the cumulative reorientation of identity.

Each moment of seeing loosens the grip of identification. Each recognition weakens the assumption that we are our moods, our reactions, or our inner narratives.

Over time, a new center of gravity emerges. Not because you held awareness longer, but because you stopped confusing awareness with effort.

When Activity Loses Its Center

Helminski makes a stark claim. Activity without Being becomes chaotic, wasteful, and misdirected. This is not a condemnation of action. It is an observation about its source.

There is a kind of energy that feels powerful but leaves exhaustion in its wake. There is a kind of productivity that accomplishes much while quietly draining everyone involved. This energy is often mistaken for effectiveness.

Being has a different signature. Actions that arise from it tend to be simpler, cleaner, and less violent, even when they are decisive. They carry less excess force.

Fastidious remembrance is not about withdrawing from life. It is about restoring proportion. When Being is present, action no longer needs to prove itself.

The Experiment That Never Ends

This is not a practice you complete. It is an experiment you repeat.

Catch yourself when you are bored. Catch yourself when you are hurried. Catch yourself when you are pleased. Catch yourself when you are annoyed.

Do not correct. Do not improve. Do not narrate.

Just see.

The pulse will come and go. Let it. Over time, you will discover that you are not entering Being at all. You are simply remembering where you already are.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

The Sacred Art of Sliding Your Identity

Virgin Monk Boy — Wed, 21 Jan 2026 16:06:54 GMT

This post grows out of work I’ve been doing with Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, which itself is a sustained engagement with Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence. In particular, it draws from the chapter titled The Power of Being. What follows is not an attempt to define identity, because identity, like Being itself, collapses the moment we try to pin it down. It emerged instead from noticing how instinctively we cling to names, roles, moods, and emotional weather patterns as if they were solid ground. And how rarely we experiment with something far more subtle and far more freeing: the capacity to shift where identity is located.

Subscribe now

The Slide Rule of the Self

Beatrice Bruteau offers one of the clearest metaphors I know for this. She suggests that our sense of self can move along a scale, like the old slide ruler inside a childhood pencil case. Most of us assume identity is fixed, something we are. But Bruteau points out that identity behaves more like a position we habitually occupy, often without realizing we could slide it elsewhere.

At the most bound end of the scale, identity is locked into nouns and roles.
I am a parent.
I am a pastor.
I am a failure.
I am the responsible one.

These identities provide structure and social traction, but they are fragile. They must be defended. They bruise easily. When life disrupts them, we feel personally threatened because the role has been carrying our sense of being.

Slide a little further, and identity loosens into adjectives and emotional states.
I am anxious.
I am creative.
I am depressed.
I am angry.

This middle territory feels more honest and psychologically sophisticated, but it is still unstable. Emotions rise and fall, yet when we say “I am angry,” we quietly fuse who we are with what is passing through us. The weather becomes the sky.

The Far End of the Scale: “I Am”

Bruteau points to another possibility at the far end of the slide. A place where identity no longer finishes the sentence with a noun or an adjective. Where it rests, unmodified, as:

I am.

No role.
No mood.
No explanation.

This is not dissociation or numbing. Grief still hurts. Anger still burns. Joy still sparkles. What changes is where identity stands in relation to those experiences. They are present, but they are no longer required to define who you are.

Spiritual maturity is not living permanently at this end of the scale. That would be neither possible nor human. The work is learning how to slide. To recognize when identity has fused with a role or a feeling, and to know how to return, even briefly, to the simple fact of being.

A Simple Practice for Sliding the Center of Identity

Kabir Helminski offers a deceptively simple practice that directly supports this movement. It looks almost too minimal to matter, but it works precisely because it bypasses the mind’s urge to analyze or improve.

On the inbreath, silently think “I”, while allowing attention to settle gently in the region of the heart.
On the outbreath, silently think “AM”, as the breath releases from the body.

Nothing else is required.

This is not an affirmation. It is not a technique for producing calm. The words “I AM” are not being used to say something about yourself. They are used to rest identity in the place where it has no qualifiers.

Most breath practices stabilize attention. This one subtly re-anchors identity.

The breath provides a neutral rhythm for the body, while “I” and “AM” escort the sense of self away from roles, moods, and narratives and into sheer existence. Thoughts and emotions continue to arise. Nothing is pushed away. The difference is that they are no longer mistaken for the one who is breathing.

The focus on the heart is not sentimental. In Sufi stream Helminski draws from, the heart is understood as a center of perception rather than emotion. Letting attention settle there helps bypass the head’s compulsion to define and manage experience.

This practice works best when approached lightly. One or two minutes is enough. A few breaths before responding to an email, while waiting at a stoplight, or in the middle of an emotional surge can be more effective than a long formal sit.

If effort creeps in, that’s your signal that identity has slid back toward the middle of the scale. Simply notice it and begin again. The aim is not to stay in “I am,” but to become familiar with it.

Identity as a Skill, Not a Prison

What begins to change over time is not your personality or your circumstances, but your relationship to them. Roles become tools rather than cages. Emotions regain their dignity without running the show. You stop needing life to cooperate in order to feel real.

Identity does not disappear.
It loosens.

And in that loosening, something deeper remembers itself, not as a story to be defended, but as a presence that was never in danger to begin with.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Am I Angry, or Am I Just Being Angry?

Virgin Monk Boy — Sun, 18 Jan 2026 13:02:27 GMT

This post grows out of work I’ve been doing with Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, which itself is a sustained engagement with Kabir Helminski’s Living Presence. In particular, it draws from the chapter titled The Power of Being. What follows is not an attempt to fix anger, manage emotions, or become a calmer, nicer version of yourself. It emerged instead from noticing how easily we confuse a passing inner weather pattern with who we actually are. How quickly we slide from “anger is present” to “this is me now.” And how much unnecessary suffering that single grammatical shift creates.

Subscribe now

Virgin Monk Boy writes across several collections, including Satire (Christian Nationalism and spiritual humor), Mary Magdalene, and Wisdom Jesus (Sufi Jesus).
This post is part of the Wisdom Jesus collection.
If you’d prefer not to receive emails from this collection, you can turn it off in Manage subscription.

When Anger Sounds Like the Truth

There is a peculiar confidence that comes with anger.

When anger arrives, it does not knock politely. It barges in like it owns the place. It speaks in full sentences, with footnotes. It carries a narrative, a backstory, and a closing argument. It does not present itself as a temporary visitor. It presents itself as truth.

“I am angry,” we say.

And that sounds harmless enough. But listen carefully to what that sentence is doing. It is not simply describing a state. It is making a claim about identity. It is saying, in effect, this is who I am right now. Not “anger is moving through the system,” but “I am this.”

The Subtle Violence of “I Am Angry”

This is where the trouble begins.

Because emotions, by their very nature, are transient. They arise. They intensify. They dissolve. They are weather, not terrain. But the moment we identify with them, we attempt to build a house in a thunderstorm and then act surprised when the roof won’t hold.

Weather Is Not the Landscape

A friend once told me a story about a fish.

Two young fish are swimming along when they pass an older fish coming the other way. The older fish nods and says, “Morning, boys. How’s the water?”

The two young fish swim on for a bit. Then one of them looks at the other and says, “What the hell is water?”

The Fish Who Didn’t Know What Water Was

The joke works because it lands on something uncomfortably true. The most fundamental realities are the hardest to see precisely because we are immersed in them. Being is like that. Presence is like that. Awareness is like that. We don’t “get” them. We inhabit them.

And yet, paradoxically, we spend most of our lives unaware of the very field that makes our lives possible.

Mistaking the Foam for the Sea

Instead, we identify with the foam.

Thoughts. Moods. Reactions. Roles. Stories. Emotional surges. These are the visible froth on the surface of experience. They are real, but they are not primary. They arise within something much larger, something quieter, something that does not fluctuate with every internal breeze.

That something is what the contemplative traditions call Being.

Being Is Not a Better Mood

Being is not a mood. It is not a personality trait. It is not calm, happy, spiritual, or enlightened. Being is the ground in which calm and agitation both appear. It is the field that holds anger without becoming angry.

This is where the question in the title becomes interesting.

Am I angry, or am I just being angry?

Identity Collapse and Emotional Possession

Those two statements may look similar, but they come from entirely different levels of consciousness.

When I say “I am angry,” I have collapsed my identity into a passing state. I have slid my sense of self all the way down to the level of emotion. Anger is no longer something happening. It is something I am. And from that place, anger doesn’t just express itself. It justifies itself. It recruits allies. It sharpens its knives.

When I say “anger is present,” something else happens. A small but decisive space opens. Not distance. Not repression. Not spiritual bypassing. Just space.

Intimacy Without Confusion

In that space, anger is allowed to be exactly what it is: energy, information, heat, intensity. It can be felt in the body. It can be honored. It can even be listened to. But it is no longer running the identity department.

This distinction matters more than we usually realize.

Most of our suffering does not come from emotions themselves. It comes from fusion with emotions. From the unconscious habit of letting whatever is loudest inside us take over the microphone and announce itself as “me.”

Hello, my name is Angry.
Hello, my name is Anxious.
Hello, my name is Hurt, Offended, Righteous, Exhausted.

Relocating the Center

Spiritual work, at least in this contemplative lineage, is not about silencing these voices. It is about relocating the center from which we listen.

There is a level of ourselves that can feel anger fully without being reduced to it. A level that can grieve without drowning. A level that can be passionate without being possessed.

This is not stoicism. It is not emotional detachment. It is not numbing out or pretending things don’t matter.

It is intimacy without confusion.

The Relief of Unhooking

Think again of the fish. The fish does not need to escape the water to know the water. It needs only to notice what has always been holding it. In the same way, we do not need to get rid of anger to find Being. We need only to stop mistaking anger for the whole of who we are.

When this noticing happens, even briefly, something subtle but profound shifts. The emotional charge does not necessarily disappear. But it loses its absolute authority. It is no longer the final word. It is one movement within a much larger field.

Standing in a Deeper Place

This is why moments of real seeing often feel strangely relieving, even when nothing has been fixed. The circumstances may be unchanged. The emotion may still be present. But the identity has been unhooked.

And that unhooking is freedom.

It allows us to act without being hijacked. To speak without being scorched by our own heat. To respond rather than react. Not because we are better people, but because we are standing in a deeper place.

Remembering Where You Already Are

The irony is that this deeper place is not exotic or rare. It is always already here. Like water to a fish. Like silence beneath sound. Like the screen on which every movie of our inner life is projected.

We lose access to it not because it leaves, but because we forget to look from there.

So the next time anger arrives, and it will, you might experiment with a gentler question. Not “Why am I like this?” Not “How do I get rid of this?” But simply:

Where am I standing right now?

Am I collapsed into the emotion, or am I aware of it?

Am I angry, or am I just being angry?

The clouds will keep moving.
The weather will keep changing.
The water will keep holding you.

You do not have to become something else.
You only have to remember where you already are.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Being Is the Body God Wears in This World

Virgin Monk Boy — Mon, 12 Jan 2026 15:19:27 GMT

This post grows out of work I’ve been doing with Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, which itself is a sustained engagement with Kabir Helminski’s book Living Presence. In particular, it draws from the chapter titled The Power of Being. What follows is not an attempt to define Being, because Being cannot be defined without being reduced. It emerged instead from noticing how often we treat Being as something we do, rather than something we enter. How easily we turn it into a project, a practice, a mood, or a spiritual achievement, and miss the more radical truth hiding in plain sight.

Virgin Monk Boy writes across several collections, including Satire (Christian Nationalism and spiritual humor), Mary Magdalene, and Wisdom Jesus (Sufi Jesus).
This post is part of the Wisdom Jesus collection.
If you’d prefer not to receive emails from this collection, you can turn it off in Manage subscription.

Subscribe now

Being Is Not Something You Do

The phrase “Being is the body God wears in this world” stops you if you let it. It refuses to stay abstract. It implies presence, texture, weight, immediacy. Not an idea about God, but a way God shows up. Not somewhere else. Here.

Most of us unconsciously assume Being is a kind of inner posture we adopt. We imagine it as something we summon through effort: quieting the mind, regulating the breath, adopting the right stance. But that assumption already puts us in the wrong relationship to it. Being is not something you perform. It is a field you fall into when you stop bracing yourself against existence.

The Electromagnetic Field of Love

Think of an electromagnetic field. You do not turn it on by trying harder. You move into it. And once you are inside it, everything behaves differently. Iron filings align. Currents shift. Forces that were previously invisible begin to exert influence. Being functions the same way. It is not a thing among things. It is the underlying coherence that allows things to appear at all.

Helminski describes Being as the great electromagnetic field of love. That metaphor matters, because love here is not sentiment. It is attraction, cohesion, participation. A field that holds without gripping. A field you cannot stand outside of, only ignore.

White Light and the Prism of Experience

This is where the prism metaphor helps. White light passes through a prism and becomes color. Red, blue, green, violet. Each wavelength distinct, measurable, nameable. But none of those colors exist independently. They are not competing realities. They are differentiations of one light.

Being is the white light. Everything we experience, bodies, emotions, thoughts, identities, events, is refracted presence. The problem is not that we see color. The problem is that we forget the light.

We live as if the colors were separate sources. As if happiness, grief, success, failure, intimacy, loss each had their own independent substance. So we chase one and flee another. Prefer blue to red. Want violet without yellow. But all of it is light, bending through conditions.

This is why Being cannot be possessed. You cannot grab white light by clutching a single color. The moment you try to hold it, you’re already working at the level of refraction.

The Point That Belongs Entirely to God

Thomas Merton spoke of this as the point vierge, the non-dimensional point at the center of the soul that belongs entirely to God. Meister Eckhart called it the ground of the soul. Helminski calls it Being. Different languages circling the same reality: there is something at the core of you that is not an object in your experience but the condition for experience itself.

This is why Being feels strangely like nothing and everything at once. It does not announce itself with fireworks. It feels more like falling backward into water you didn’t realize was holding you.

Action With Being, Action Without It

When you touch it, even briefly, the quality of action changes. Not because you are calmer or wiser or nicer, but because action is no longer driven by the frantic need to secure identity. You are no longer acting from lack, but from contact.

This is where the phrase “Being is the body God wears in this world” becomes more than poetry. If Being is God’s body, then everything that exists is occurring within God, not merely created by God at a distance. Life itself is the sacrament.

Can Anything Fall Out of Being?

And that raises an unsettling question: can anything fall out of Being?

We live as though it can. We fear abandonment, annihilation, meaninglessness. We construct elaborate psychological selves to defend against the terror of falling away. But if Being is the field in which existence happens, then even death cannot eject you from it. Forms dissolve. Colors recombine. But the light does not disappear.

This is why Being is inseparable from mercy. Mercy is not God overlooking your failures. Mercy is the fact that existence itself continues to hold you, regardless of your success or collapse. The field does not withdraw when you falter. It does not punish refraction.

The Subtle Violence of Using Being

The tragedy of most spiritual practice is that we try to use Being to fix our lives. We approach it as a technique for stress reduction, emotional regulation, or moral improvement. And in doing so, we keep ourselves at arm’s length from the very thing we seek. Being is not a tool. It is the ground you are standing on while you reach for tools.

This is why Bourgeault emphasizes noticing the difference between actions done with Being and actions done without it. The difference is visceral. Without Being, activity becomes compulsive, scattered, force-driven. Even when it looks productive, it leaves exhaustion and damage in its wake. With Being, action may be quieter, slower, or paradoxically more decisive, but it carries a different fragrance. Less noise. Less violence.

Presence Is Not Passivity

Importantly, this has nothing to do with withdrawing from the world. Falling into Being does not make you passive. It makes you accurate. Action arising from contact does not need self-importance to fuel it. It does not need enemies to justify itself. It moves because movement is required, not because the ego is restless.

The Pulse of Consciousness

You do not stay in Being continuously. At least not at first. Consciousness pulses. You glimpse it. Lose it. Glimpse it again. That is not failure. That is how the field teaches you its rhythm. Each pulse weakens the illusion that you are the doer, the fixer, the manager of reality.

Eventually something shifts. You stop trying to be present and begin to notice that presence is already there. You stop asking how to enter Being and begin to notice that you never left.

The Only Real Choice

And that may be the most radical implication of all. Being is not waiting for you at the end of spiritual effort. It is what you are made of. What the world is made of. What God wears when God shows up as breath, as grief, as joy, as this moment, exactly as it is.

The only real choice is whether you will notice the field you are already standing in, or continue mistaking the colors for separate suns.

If you’re curious how this shows up in you, there are a few quizzes here :-)

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Happiness Is a Mirage. Truth Is a River.

Virgin Monk Boy — Mon, 05 Jan 2026 15:18:27 GMT

This essay grows out of work I’ve been doing with Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, which itself is a sustained engagement with Kabir Helminski’s book Living Presence. In particular, it draws from the chapter titled “The Power of Being.” What follows is not a theoretical argument about happiness or joy. It emerged the way these insights usually do, not from ideal conditions or well-managed spiritual practice, but from friction. From noticing how often the pursuit of feeling good quietly substitutes for depth, and how easily we mistake pleasant states for something solid enough to live from.

Subscribe now

Virgin Monk Boy writes across several collections, including Satire (Christian Nationalism and spiritual humor), Mary Magdalene, and Wisdom Jesus (Sufi Jesus).
This post is part of the Wisdom Jesus collection.
If you’d prefer not to receive emails from this collection, you can turn it off in Manage subscription.

The Mirage We Keep Walking Toward

Happiness is not an illusion in the crude sense. It is real enough to convince us. That is precisely the problem.

It arrives when things improve. It blooms when desires are met. It rewards us when life briefly cooperates. And because it feels warm, affirming, and alive, we quietly assume it must be what spiritual life is meant to deliver.

But happiness is structurally dependent. It exists because something happened, because something aligned, because something satisfied a want. When the condition changes, the state dissolves. Nothing went wrong. That is simply how happiness works.

And yet we treat it as if it were a foundation.

This is how a mirage functions. It is not imaginary. It reflects light accurately. It even appears where water might reasonably be expected. But it cannot quench thirst. The closer you walk toward it, the more exhausted you become.

The tragedy is not wanting happiness. The tragedy is organizing a life around it.

The Quiet Violence of the Pain–Pleasure Cycle

When happiness becomes the aim, life collapses into a subtle but relentless loop.

Desire promises relief. Relief fades. Desire returns. The object changes. The hunger does not.

At first this looks like normal ambition, normal growth, normal striving. Over time it becomes something else. A nervous system trained to scan constantly for improvement. A self defined by its current emotional weather. A spirituality that quietly turns into mood management.

Nothing is ever wrong enough to justify stopping. Nothing is ever good enough to justify resting.

This is not a moral failure. It is not a lack of discipline. It is the inevitable outcome of placing identity in states that cannot stay.

As long as happiness is treated as the measure of a good life, dissatisfaction remains baked into the system.

Why Serenity Is Not Emotional Sweetness

Every serious spiritual tradition eventually draws a line here.

Not by rejecting happiness, but by relativizing it.

What emerges instead is often called serenity, peace, or equanimity. These words are frequently misunderstood. They are not emotional anesthesia. They do not mean feeling calm all the time. They do not mean grief disappears or anger evaporates.

Serenity means the center holds.

It means you can be unhappy without being undone. You can grieve without losing your footing. You can experience fear without being swallowed by it.

This is why serenity feels unimpressive to the modern spiritual imagination. It does not sparkle. It does not peak. It does not trend well on social media.

But it endures.

And even serenity, in these teachings, is not the final depth.

From Serenity to Being

Serenity arises when attention sinks below emotional states into something more elemental.

This is what the chapter names being.

Being is not a feeling. It does not come and go. It does not improve when life improves or deteriorate when life becomes difficult. Being is what allows happiness and unhappiness to arise in the first place.

When identity shifts from emotional conditions to being itself, a strange loosening occurs.

Happiness no longer needs to be clung to.
Unhappiness no longer needs to be resisted.

Neither is rejected. Neither is privileged. They are no longer asked to carry the weight of meaning.

They pass through.

Truth Is Not a Concept You Agree With

This is where the central claim becomes visible.

Truth, in this teaching, is not an idea you assent to. It is alignment with reality as it is, beneath preference and resistance. Seeking truth means relinquishing the demand that life feel a certain way in order to be acceptable.

This is why seeking truth yields joy, while seeking joy yields mirages.

Joy here is not excitement. It is not cheerfulness. It is not perpetual uplift. It is the quiet, grounded recognition that nothing essential is missing, even when something hurts.

Joy flows because it is no longer demanded.

The River Does Not Promise Comfort

A river does not guarantee calm waters. It guarantees continuity.

You can step into it while grieving. You can remain in it while afraid. You can act from it without panic, righteousness, or self-importance.

This is why mature spirituality eventually stops selling happiness and starts cultivating truth. Not because happiness is bad, but because it is too small to carry a human life.

The mirage keeps you walking.
The river invites you to enter.

And once you do, something becomes clear in a way no argument could ever prove:

Joy was never something to chase.
It was something that followed when the chase ended.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

The Moment You See, Everything Changes

Virgin Monk Boy — Wed, 31 Dec 2025 17:26:56 GMT

This reflection is part of an ongoing series inspired by the audio course Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, taught by Cynthia Bourgeault and rooted in The Power of Being, a chapter from Living Presence. As with earlier essays in this series, the intention here is not to summarize the teaching but to stay close to its inner pressure, to notice where it unsettles our usual spiritual assumptions rather than reassuring them.

Subscribe now

This chapter does not give us a new practice to master. Instead, it quietly removes one of our most deeply held habits: the belief that spiritual transformation happens by fixing ourselves. What it offers in its place is far more disarming. It suggests that what changes us is not effort, but seeing.

The Reflex to Fix

Most of us are conditioned to believe that change comes through effort. When something feels wrong, uncomfortable, or unresolved, our reflex is immediate and unquestioned: it must be addressed. Something is off, so something must be done. This assumption runs so deep that it rarely appears to us as an assumption at all. It simply feels like common sense.

Spiritual practice often absorbs this reflex without noticing it. Prayer becomes technique. Awareness becomes discipline. Presence becomes something we try to maintain, measure, or improve. Even mindfulness, which begins as a doorway into immediacy, can quietly turn into another form of management, another way of keeping ourselves under supervision.

But The Power of Being introduces a claim that cuts directly against this pattern. Transformation, it says, does not come from fixing or forcing. It comes from seeing. And seeing is not something we do over time. It is not cumulative. It is not gradual. Seeing happens all at once, or not at all.

Seeing Is Not Mindfulness

One of the most important distinctions in this chapter is the difference between mindfulness and seeing. Mindfulness, as it is usually practiced, unfolds in time. It strings moments together, asking us to slow down, regulate attention, and sustain awareness across duration. There is nothing inherently wrong with this, but it operates within sequence and continuity. It depends on rhythm and pace.

Seeing does not.

Seeing happens in an instant. It does not require calm conditions or inner order. It does not wait for the nervous system to settle or the psyche to cooperate. You can see yourself being reactive while you are still reactive. You can see yourself rushing while you are still late. You can see yourself grasping without first letting go.

And when that seeing happens, something shifts immediately. Not because the behavior has changed, but because illusion cannot survive direct perception. What was previously fused with identity becomes visible, and the moment it becomes visible, it loosens its grip.

Spiritual Life Is Not a Fixing Project

This is where the teaching becomes genuinely destabilizing. We tend to assume that awareness is valuable only if it changes conditions. If noticing does not lead to improvement, we quietly judge it as ineffective. But Bourgeault, drawing on Helminski’s work, keeps pointing us back to a more radical truth: spiritual life is not a fixing project at all. It is a seeing project.

When we see without resistance, without commentary, without the reflex to intervene, something in us stops tightening. The false self, which survives by believing it must constantly manage reality, loses its fuel. We stop rehearsing explanations. We stop narrating ourselves. And in that release, being enters—not as a feeling or a mood, but as a field in which experience can be held without distortion.

Mistaking Force for Presence

This helps explain why so much of our effort leaves us exhausted and unchanged. We often mistake force for presence, intensity for depth, and activity for aliveness. A life can be packed with meaning, responsibility, and even spiritual ambition, and still be strangely hollow. Another life, outwardly constrained by grief, limitation, or unfinished business, can feel deeply alive because it is rooted somewhere deeper than circumstances.

Being does not erase emotion. It does not bypass grief or flatten experience. It holds it. And from that holding, action begins to look different. It becomes quieter, cleaner, less driven by urgency or the need to prove something.

Seeing in the Middle of Chaos

One of the most liberating implications of this teaching is that seeing does not require ideal conditions. You do not need to slow down in order to see. You do not need to become mindful first. Seeing can happen in the middle of chaos.

You can notice your agitation without calming it. You can notice your hurry without slowing it. You can notice your anxiety without resolving it. The noticing itself is sufficient, not as a tactic, but as a revelation. Something in the structure of consciousness reorders itself the moment truth is allowed to appear without resistance.

The Power of Being

Once this is glimpsed, even briefly, the spiritual path changes. The question is no longer how to manage your inner life, but whether you are willing to see what is actually here without trying to make it acceptable. When that happens, something fundamental shifts.

The moment you see, everything changes. Not because the moment itself is different, but because you are no longer hiding from it. And that, quietly and unmistakably, is the power of being.

A Virgin Monk Boy Insight

Here is the quiet heresy hidden inside all of this, offered in the tone it deserves:

Presence is not something that arrives when conditions are finally right. It is what becomes visible when the habit of looking away relaxes. Seeing does not wait for readiness or self-improvement. It appears the moment resistance loosens.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

The False God of Fixing Things

Virgin Monk Boy — Sat, 27 Dec 2025 17:47:38 GMT

This post continues a series drawn from Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, especially the chapter often called The Power of Being. If the previous piece, How to Stay Human When You’re Running Late, explored presence under pressure, this one looks at what happens when pressure dresses itself up as virtue. Specifically, the Western compulsion to fix, correct, intervene, and save the world while remaining profoundly unacquainted with our own interior weather.

Subscribe now

A Confession Before We Begin

Let’s begin with a confession.

The West loves action. We adore motion with a moral narrative. We trust the person who is doing something far more than the person who is becoming something. If you are calm, quiet, or inwardly attentive while the world is burning, we assume you are either privileged, complicit, or dead inside.

This is how fixing became a god.

Not service.
Not love.
Fixing.

The Posture and Psychology of Fixing

Fixing has a posture. Chin slightly raised. Jaw set. Eyes scanning for error. It thrives on urgency and feeds on outrage. It requires an enemy, a problem, or at minimum a poorly phrased sentence on the internet.

Fixing reassures us that we are on the right side of history, which conveniently means we never have to examine the state of our own being.

Virgin Monk Boy translation: if your activism needs adrenaline to survive, it is not wisdom. It is a stimulant.

When Action Becomes a Spiritual Distraction

This is where the inner path throws a wrench into the whole enterprise. The contemplative traditions are deeply suspicious of action that does not arise from stillness. Not because action is bad, but because action without being is noisy, violent, and strangely ineffective.

The great illusion is that more effort equals more impact.

What actually changes the world is presence with density.

Coherence Beats Force

Take Mahatma Gandhi. The caricature says he defeated an empire by protest. The deeper truth is that he defeated an empire by coherence. His actions worked because they were not reactions. They arose from an interior alignment that could not be manipulated, provoked, or rushed.

When action came, it was precise, minimal, and devastatingly effective. He was not fixing Britain. He was embodying truth until the lie collapsed under its own weight.

The Slow Power of the Quakers

Or consider the Quakers. Their social reforms did not emerge from fury or ideology. They emerged from silence. From waiting. From a ruthless commitment to act only when action had ripened inwardly.

This is why their impact on abolition, prison reform, and peace movements far outstripped their numbers. They refused to substitute agitation for clarity.

Modern activism would find them unbearably slow.

Which is exactly the point.

Simone Weil and the Danger of Moral Superiority

And then there is Simone Weil, who may be the most uncomfortable cameo of all. Weil distrusted activism that allowed the activist to feel morally superior. She warned that attention, real attention, is the rarest and purest form of generosity. Not attention as performance, but attention as surrender. To see without immediately fixing. To witness suffering without needing to convert it into a personal identity project.

She understood something the West still resists: ungrounded compassion turns cruel.

Stillness Is Not Passivity

Here is the paradox that wrecks our favorite binaries. Stillness is not passivity. Inner equanimity is not disengagement. In fact, action that arises from inner stillness carries a different quality altogether.

It is not compulsive.
It is not self-referential.
It does not need applause, agreement, or even success.

It simply does what needs to be done.

Seeing Is Already an Action

This is what the contemplative traditions mean when they say that seeing is already an action. The moment you see clearly, without distortion, something shifts. You may still act. You may write the letter, march, vote, intervene, or protect.

But the action is no longer fueled by the need to be right or to discharge your own anxiety.

Ungrounded action, by contrast, always produces two byproducts: issues and self-importance.

Issues harden the heart.
Self-importance justifies harm.

Together, they guarantee that even your good deeds will carry a subtle violence.

Why Modern Activism Feels Exhausting

This is why so much modern activism feels exhausting rather than liberating. It multiplies noise without increasing wisdom. It generates heat without light. It treats the world like a machine with broken parts instead of a living field that responds to coherence.

Virgin Monk Boy observation: the universe does not respond to your outrage. It responds to your state.

The Line We Don’t Want to Hear

The spiritual traditions insist on something deeply offensive to the fix-it reflex.

You cannot heal what you are not willing to inhabit.
You cannot bring peace into a situation you are not carrying within yourself.
And you cannot shortcut being with behavior.

This does not mean withdrawing from the world. It means withdrawing your ego from the driver’s seat.

The Signature of Action Born from Being

Action born from being has a different signature. It is quieter. Often smaller. Sometimes invisible. It does not announce itself as moral. It does not need to convince everyone.

It tends to arrive late by activist standards and early by historical ones.

And yes, it may mean doing less.

Which terrifies a culture addicted to urgency.

The Sacred Roast (Delivered Gently)

The false god of fixing demands constant sacrifice. Your nervous system. Your relationships. Your joy. Your capacity to listen. It promises relevance and delivers burnout. It flatters you into believing that without your intervention, nothing good can happen.

Stillness tells a different story. It says that being itself is already at work. That reality does not need you frantic to be healed. That your task is not to save the world but to stop fragmenting it further with unexamined action.

So here is the sacred roast, gently delivered.

If your activism leaves you perpetually angry, you are not awake.
If your certainty is growing faster than your compassion, you are not helping.
If your sense of self depends on opposing someone else, you are worshiping the wrong god.

Where Real Power Actually Begins

Start where the real power is.

Not in fixing.
In seeing.
Not in reaction.
In presence.
Not in noise.
In being.

From there, act.

Or don’t.

Either way, the world will finally feel the difference.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

How to Stay Human When You’re Running Late

Virgin Monk Boy — Sun, 21 Dec 2025 16:43:50 GMT

This essay grows out of the same soil as the reflections I’ve been writing alongside Cynthia Bourgeault’s course Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, particularly the material gathered around The Power of Being chapter in Living Presence: A Sufi Way to Mindfulness & the Essential Self by Kabir Helminski. The ideas here are not theoretical. They emerged the way most honest spiritual insights do, not from quiet monasteries or carefully scheduled prayer times, but from friction. From hurry. From a sharp exchange about rushing that exposed how quickly we abandon our humanity and call it necessity.

Subscribe now

What follows is not advice for becoming a serene saint behind the wheel, nor a call to perform mindfulness theater while the clock is screaming. It’s an exploration of how presence actually functions when things are already unraveling.

Because if a spiritual teaching only works when life is calm, it’s not a teaching. It’s a luxury.

The Moment Hurry Takes Over

Running late is one of the clearest laboratories for watching the false self seize command. The body tightens. The breath shortens. Attention narrows to a single outcome. Time becomes an enemy. Other people transform into obstacles. The inner narration sharpens into a low-grade aggression that disguises itself as efficiency.

Nothing overtly dramatic is happening, yet something essential quietly vanishes.

You’re no longer here.

And that disappearance is so normalized that we barely notice it. We say things like “I didn’t have time to be present,” as if presence were an optional add-on instead of the ground of being itself.

But the problem is not the rushing.

The problem is the loss of being while rushing.

Presence Is Not the Opposite of Speed

One of the most persistent spiritual myths is that presence requires slowness. That to be grounded, awake, or spiritually aligned, life must move at a monk’s pace. This assumption quietly disqualifies half of real life from spiritual relevance.

Presence does not require a change of speed.
It requires a change of center.

You can move quickly and remain rooted.
You can move slowly and be completely gone.

Speed is not the enemy. Unconsciousness is.

The inner tradition has always made this distinction. Presence is not a mood. It is not calmness. It is not a pleasant feeling state. Presence is the simple, radical capacity to see what is happening while it is happening without collapsing into it and without trying to fix it.

Seeing Instead of Fixing

When you’re running late, the practice is not to stop running late.

The practice is to notice what running late does to your sense of self.

Watch how identity contracts.
Watch how attention tunnels.
Watch how the future colonizes the present.
Watch how the body braces as if time itself were a predator.

That seeing alone is already a return to being.

This is where many people get stuck. They assume presence means replacing chaos with peace. But peace is not something you impose on chaos. Peace is what happens when chaos is fully seen without resistance.

Seeing is instantaneous.
Mindfulness unfolds in time.

Presence flashes. It does not require rehearsal.

You Don’t Need Better Techniques

In moments of hurry, people often reach for tools. Breathwork. Mantras. Self-talk. Techniques designed to calm the system back down. There is nothing wrong with these practices, but they are often misused as control strategies.

Presence is not achieved by managing yourself into a better state.

You don’t need to breathe differently.
You don’t need to narrate your experience.
You don’t need to perform calm.

You simply need to register, cleanly and without judgment, “This is hurry.”

Not “I am bad for hurrying.”
Not “I should be calmer.”
Not “This isn’t spiritual.”

Just: this is hurry.

The moment you see it, something subtle shifts. You may still be late. You may still move quickly. But the cruelty drains out of the motion. You stop leaking aggression into the world. You stop recruiting imaginary enemies.

You become human again inside the mess.

The Quiet Anguish That Opens the Door

There is a particular kind of inner ache that appears when you know there is a better way to be, but you don’t have time to access it. Most people either numb this discomfort or spiritualize it away.

But that ache is not a failure.
It is awareness knocking.

It is the friction between how you are moving and what you know to be true. The practice is not to eliminate that tension, but to let it be felt without commentary.

This is where transformation actually begins.

Not by fixing the conditions.
Not by correcting the behavior.
But by allowing being to touch the moment as it is.

Action That Is Not Violent

Action sourced from being has a different texture. It is precise without being frantic. Focused without being brittle. It moves quickly without trampling everything it touches.

Action sourced from unconsciousness always carries collateral damage, even when it “works.” You can feel the difference afterward. One leaves residue. The other does not.

Presence doesn’t make life slower.
It makes life less brutal.

Staying Human in the Middle of It

You don’t have to fix your hurry.
You don’t have to justify it.
You don’t have to turn it into a lesson.

Just see it.

Let awareness widen for a fraction of a second. Let being brush up against the moment. That is enough. Presence works in pulses, not performances.

The irony is that when you stop trying to be mindful and allow yourself to be present, something humane reenters the scene. You may still arrive late, but you arrive intact.

And that matters more than we’ve been taught to believe.

The practice is simple, but not easy.

Catch yourself in the act of losing yourself.
See it.
Don’t correct it.
Don’t dramatize it.

Presence does not slow the world down.
It gives you back to it.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

I Am Not My Mood: Escaping the Pain-Pleasure Cycle

Virgin Monk Boy — Tue, 16 Dec 2025 15:25:51 GMT

Feelings come and go. You don’t have to go with them.

This post grows out of the same soil as “Stop Chasing Feelings. Start Sourcing from Being.” It draws again from the audio course Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, particularly the material that weaves together Kabir Helminski’s clarity around being with Cynthia Bourgeault’s insistence that maturity in the spiritual life means learning where to stand when everything inside you is moving. The question underneath this chapter is deceptively simple. If emotions are constantly changing, what exactly are we standing on when we say “this is who I am”?

Subscribe now

The Quiet Way We Turn Feelings into Identity

Most of us answer that question without ever noticing we are answering it. We identify ourselves with whatever state happens to be loudest at the moment. I am happy. I am anxious. I am angry. I am inspired. I am crushed. These are not just descriptions of experience. They quietly become claims of identity. And once that happens, the nervous system locks into the ancient pain-pleasure loop. We chase what feels good, we resist what hurts, and we oscillate endlessly between the two, mistaking intensity for aliveness and relief for freedom.

Why Emotional States Are Unstable Ground

The problem is not that emotions exist. The problem is that emotions are unstable ground. They are weather, not climate. They move, they peak, they collapse, and they give way to something else. No emotional state, no matter how exalted, has ever stayed. Ecstasy fades. Motivation burns out. Even grief eventually changes texture. When identity is built on what cannot remain, insecurity becomes inevitable. The self must constantly defend, prolong, justify, or relive its preferred state, because without it, it does not know who it is.

What the Inner Tradition Sees Differently

This is where the inner tradition parts ways with both modern psychology and pop spirituality. The goal is not to eliminate emotion, nor to replace “negative” feelings with “positive” ones. The goal is to relocate identity. Equanimity is not indifference. It is not numbness. It is not the flattening of affect or the suppression of grief, anger, or joy. Equanimity is what emerges when the center of gravity drops beneath the emotional field into being itself.

Being as the Ground Beneath Every State

Being is not a mood. It does not rise or fall. It does not need to be improved, stimulated, or maintained. It is the silent continuity underneath every state. When Helminski says that happiness and unhappiness are both superficial, he is not dismissing them. He is putting them in their proper place. They are experiences within consciousness, not the seat of consciousness itself. When Paul speaks of a peace that passes understanding, he is pointing to this same ground. Not a pleasant feeling, but a stability that does not depend on conditions.

Why Equanimity Can Feel Threatening at First

The reason equanimity feels threatening at first is because the ego survives by emotional attachment. It defines itself by intensity. If I am my anger, then my anger gives me coherence. If I am my sadness, then my sadness gives me depth. If I am my joy, then joy gives me worth. To loosen identification feels like annihilation. But what actually dissolves is not life. It is the false assumption that life requires constant emotional reinforcement to exist.

Learning to Hear the Difference Between “I Feel” and “I Am”

One of the most practical shifts on this path is learning to hear the difference between “I feel” and “I am.” “I feel angry” is an observation. “I am angry” is an identity claim. The first allows space. The second collapses it. The inner tradition trains the observer not to judge emotions, but to refuse to enthrone them. Anger can be present without becoming king. Grief can move through without being named the truth of who you are.

What Equanimity Actually Does to Feeling

Equanimity does not mean you stop caring. In fact, it is the opposite. When identity is no longer fused to emotional weather, emotions can be felt more fully, not less. Grief can be honored without drowning in it. Joy can be enjoyed without clinging. Anger can be listened to without obeyed. The difference is that something deeper is holding the experience. There is a witness that does not need to defend itself against what is arising.

Three Signs You’re Clinging to a Feeling as Identity

So how do you recognize when you are clinging to a feeling as self-definition?

The first sign is language. Notice how often your inner narrative uses emotional states as nouns rather than experiences. “This is just who I am.” “I’m an anxious person.” “I’m not a happy person.” These sound like self-knowledge, but they are actually contracts with impermanence. Begin gently translating identity statements back into experiential ones. Not to correct yourself harshly, but to introduce truth. This is not denial. It is accuracy.

The second sign is urgency. When a feeling feels like it must be expressed, resolved, justified, or fixed immediately in order for you to be okay, identity has likely fused with state. Equanimity introduces patience. It allows the system to feel without panicking. If you cannot let an emotion exist without acting from it, chances are high that you are standing on it.

The third sign is narrative amplification. Emotions naturally come with energy. Identity feeds that energy with story. The story explains why the feeling is right, permanent, or defining. Watch how quickly the mind rushes in to give a feeling a biography. This is not something to suppress. It is something to see. Seeing alone begins to loosen the knot.

A Simple Question That Reorients the Center

A simple practice is to pause and ask, without drama, “What is aware of this feeling?” Do not answer conceptually. Let the question turn attention backward. Even briefly, you may notice a subtle shift. The feeling is still there, but it is no longer alone. That shift is the beginning of equanimity. It does not require effort. It requires honesty.

Sliding Identity Without Forcing It

Another practice is to experiment with sliding your identity, as Beatrice Bruteau described. Notice when the sense of “I” is lodged in an emotion. Then, without forcing, let it rest for a moment in the bare sense of being. Not “I am angry,” not “I am calm,” but simply “I am.” This is not a mantra. It is a recognition. Even a second is enough. Over time, those seconds begin to string themselves together.

Freedom Beneath the Pain-Pleasure Cycle

None of this means that life becomes flat. In fact, life becomes more textured. Emotional states stop being verdicts and start being information. They come, they speak, they pass. You remain. This is the freedom hidden beneath the pain-pleasure cycle. Not the absence of feeling, but the end of emotional tyranny.

The irony is that when you stop chasing happiness, happiness becomes less desperate. When you stop fearing sadness, sadness becomes less threatening. Equanimity does not cancel joy. It frees it from demand. It allows joy to be joy, not proof that life is working.

You are not your mood. You never were. Moods are visitors. Being is home.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Stop Chasing Feelings. Start Sourcing from Being

Virgin Monk Boy — Thu, 11 Dec 2025 16:51:03 GMT

Some of us chase spiritual highs the way others chase stock tips. Always hoping the next meditation, teacher, or workshop will finally fix our mess and lift us into the clouds. But Chapter 6 of Practicing Living Presence: Discovering the Mind of Christ Within, titled “The Power of Being,” is a loving wrecking ball to that approach. Cynthia Bourgeault, drawing on Kabir Helminski’s Sufi framework, invites us to unhook from our addiction to experience and instead ground ourselves in what she calls Being—the living, breathing, stabilizing force of presence itself.

Subscribe now

She doesn’t just describe it. She builds a case for why almost all of our spiritual frustration comes from not knowing how to source from Being. The problem isn’t that God is hiding. The problem is we’re still checking our spiritual pulse every five seconds looking for a sign instead of trusting the quiet radiance that’s already here.

Let’s get into it.

Your Feelings Are Not the Truth

Bourgeault opens with a much-needed gut check: our feelings are real, but they’re not always true.

In contemplative language, this is called disidentification—learning to feel what you feel without fusing your identity to the storyline. The idea that “I am my anger” or “I am my fatigue” is a trap. Most people in spiritual practice never fully escape it because they mistake intensity for depth and assume that whatever they’re feeling most strongly must be the most honest thing about them.

Spoiler: it’s not.

Feelings are like weather—they come, they go, and sometimes they throw a tornado warning just to see if you’re paying attention. But the self that notices? That watches? That gently waits instead of reacting? That’s the beginning of Being.

Sourcing from the Deep Well

Bourgeault uses the word Being with a capital B to signal something deeper than the personality or even the ordinary sense of “self.” In Helminski’s Sufi terms, this is the Essential Self—the part of us that’s stable, spacious, and rooted in divine reality.

Most people are living from what Kabir calls “the reactive self.” We’re like foam riding on the surface of the ocean, constantly tossed around by whatever wave comes next. Sourcing from Being means you stop living at the surface and start living from the deep well inside. Not because it makes you feel better (though it might), but because it’s true.

And truth, it turns out, has its own gravity. You can learn to trust it more than your emotions. More than your thoughts. More than your next dopamine hit from that “spiritual” podcast you listened to while scrolling Instagram.

The Shift from Horizontal to Vertical

Here’s where Cynthia gets subtly revolutionary. Most of us are trying to fix our horizontal life. Better relationships, less anxiety, a more fulfilling job, deeper spiritual insight. But the real transformation doesn’t happen on the horizontal axis. It happens vertically—by awakening to Being and letting that quality filter into every horizontal moment.

Think of the vertical axis as your soul’s umbilical cord to the Source. When you’re sourcing from Being, you’re not just reacting to life—you’re radiating something into it. The horizontal gets infused rather than fixed.

Virgin Monk Boy would say it like this: “Trying to rearrange the horizontal without accessing the vertical is like feng shui-ing your prison cell and calling it freedom.”

Embodiment Over Abstraction

This teaching is not just philosophical—it’s felt. Cynthia emphasizes embodiment again and again. The body is not a distraction from presence. It is the anchor. She says:

“The more deeply we are in our bodies, the more capable we are of bearing the intensity of Being.”

You don’t learn presence from thinking about it. You learn it by feeling the difference between being fused to your mood and observing your mood with kindness. You learn it when you sense your feet on the floor, your breath in your belly, and you realize: Oh. I’m still here.

That moment is not exciting. But it’s honest. And that’s where Being lives.

The Traps of Spiritual Narcissism

Let’s talk about one of the most uncomfortable insights in Chapter 6: the self-absorption of spiritual growth.

A lot of folks in the “woke and wounded” crowd secretly think that suffering = depth. They believe that if they’re going through a dark night, they must be on the fast track to enlightenment. But what if that’s just another performance? Another identity?

Bourgeault gently exposes how we can use our suffering as a way to remain in our small self. And she dares to ask us to let go of the drama.

Not by bypassing. But by turning our attention toward the still, silent presence that already knows who we are, without the wound-story.

This doesn’t mean you don’t feel pain. It means your pain isn’t the compass anymore.

You Don’t Have to Wait Until You “Feel Ready”

Chapter 6 ends with a liberating reminder: you don’t have to feel ready to show up in Being. In fact, you probably won’t. You’ll probably feel unsure, scattered, overwhelmed, or underwhelmed. And none of that disqualifies you.

Presence isn’t something you achieve by feeling perfect. It’s something you consent to—right now, in the middle of your cluttered desk and unanswered texts.

You give your attention to it like you would to a sleeping child or a candle flickering in the dark.

And slowly, it starts to burn brighter.

Final Word from the (Virgin) Monk

If you’ve made it this far, congrats. You’ve already begun. Because presence isn’t a concept you learn. It’s a dimension of being you remember. Chapter 6 is a reminder that God isn’t hiding behind your trauma, your mood, or your circumstances. God’s hanging out in the very center of them, quietly humming the frequency of Being—and waiting for you to tune in.

The less you try to feel something, the more you realize something’s already here.

So stop chasing the vibe.

And start sourcing from the Real.

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls is a free publication.
If these words steady you, challenge you, make you laugh, or help you breathe deeper, here are three simple ways to support the work.

Share the Scrolls

Passing a link forward is how more wandering souls stumble into the monastery. Word of mouth is the whole engine.

Become a Supporting Member

Paid members unlock the Virgin Monk Boy Book Of Hours, Whispers from the Silence, and the ability to start threads and share their own Substacks in the private chat.

Get 20% Off Forever!

Tip with a coffee

A one time gift of holy caffeine that fuels both the monk and the Magdalene movement. ☕🔥

Your presence alone already helps.
Your support keeps the lantern lit for everyone else.

The Virgin Monk Boy Scrolls: Wisdom Jesus

Why Daydreaming Isn’t the Creative Genius You Think It Is

The Cult of the Wandering Mind

Sensitive Energy Is Not Consciousness

The Imaginal Is Not Fantasy With Better Lighting

Presence Is Not Trying Harder

Creativity Needs a Vessel

Don’t Beat Yourself Up. Just Wake Up.

A Small Practice for the Imaginal

The Real Muse Is Presence

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

Share the Scrolls

Become a Supporting Member

Tip with a coffee

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Recommended Reading

Presence Changes the Room

Attention Is Not Just Personal

Every Room Has Weather

Presence Is Not Control

The Airport Becomes a Chapel

Sacred Space Is Made by Being

The Toilet Brush as Spiritual Director

One Present Person Gives the Room Another Option

Stop Donating Your Unconsciousness to the Room

Scattered Attention Drains the Soul

Presence Makes Action Cleaner

The Practice Is Not to Make the Room Worse

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

Share the Scrolls

Become a Supporting Member

Tip with a coffee

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Recommended Reading

Real Will Isn’t Willpower

Acting From the Center Instead of the Script

The Script Wearing Your Face

Willfulness Loves a Costume

Real Will Begins With Seeing

The Pause Is Not Passive

Willpower Tries to Win. Real Will Tries to Serve.

Freedom Is Not Doing Whatever You Want

The Center Is Quieter Than the Script

The Practice Is Right Here

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

Share the Scrolls

Become a Supporting Member

Tip with a coffee

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Recommended Reading

How to Watch Yourself Slip Out the Back Door

The Small Vanishings

How Attention Gets Stolen

The Witness Does Not Scream

Why Gentleness Matters

Ordinary Life Is the Training Ground

Catching Yourself in the Act

Coming Back Without Romance

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

Share the Scrolls

Become a Supporting Member

Tip with a coffee

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy

Recommended Reading

You Don’t Have to Like It to Pay Attention

Where Preference Hides

The Attention That Gets Captured

What We Mistake for Authenticity

The Practice of Showing Up Anyway

What Changes When You Stay

Beyond Like and Dislike

The Soul Gets Built Here

What This Looks Like in Ordinary Life

The Freedom on the Other Side

Returning Without Romance

Keep the Scrolls Unrolling

Share the Scrolls

Become a Supporting Member

Tip with a coffee

Follow (or troll) Virgin Monk Boy